| |
|
 |

 |
|
5.0
RESULTS
| 5.1
|
Summary
Statistics of Levels of Air Pollutants and Meteorological
Variables
Tables
5 and 5a present the summary statistics of various measures
of daily concentrations of individual pollutants and
meteorological variables for the study period (1994
- 95, and the first half of 1996). The mean daily values
are well below the Air Quality Objectives set by the
Environmental Protection Department. Mean daily levels
of air pollutants are generally higher in the first
half-year of 1996 than in 1994 - 95, with an increase
of 3% for RSP, 5% for NO2, 14% for SO2 and 36% for O3.
| Table
5: |
Summary
statistics of daily pollutant concentrations and
meteorological variables (1994-95) |
|
Mean |
SD |
Min |
P25 |
Median |
P75 |
Max |
| NO2
max |
84.97 |
32.61 |
25.13 |
59.53 |
81.44 |
108.41 |
194.40 |
| NO2
mean |
53.67 |
18.83 |
16.41 |
39.93 |
51.39 |
66.50 |
122.44 |
| O3
max (24hr) |
52.90 |
29.01 |
1.50 |
26.50 |
51.50 |
75.00 |
222.00 |
| O3
mean (24hr) |
26.66 |
18.22 |
0.20 |
10.67 |
20.65 |
39.30 |
88.07 |
| O3
mean (8hr) |
28.69 |
20.70 |
0 |
11.73 |
24.13 |
43.72 |
207.00 |
| SO2
max |
47.93 |
33.32 |
4.67 |
23.93 |
35.95 |
63.20 |
226.50 |
| SO2
mean |
20.18 |
11.35 |
2.74 |
12.43 |
17.10 |
25.05 |
68.49 |
| RSP
max |
81.90 |
39.06 |
23.17 |
51.01 |
71.80 |
106.16 |
320.42 |
| RSP
mean |
50.12 |
24.33 |
14.77 |
30.64 |
44.57 |
65.44 |
159.73 |
| Temp
mean |
22.72 |
5.11 |
9.34 |
18.40 |
24.00 |
27.15 |
30.96 |
| Temp
min |
20.32 |
5.29 |
6.61 |
15.97 |
21.86 |
24.90 |
28.35 |
| Hum
max |
89.77 |
7.40 |
47.29 |
87.00 |
91.85 |
94.67 |
96.33 |
| Hum
mean |
77.92 |
10.85 |
32.33 |
73.41 |
80.14 |
85.00 |
96.33 |
| Table
5a: |
Summary
statistics of daily pollutant concentrations and
meteorologicalvariables (1996, first half)
|
|
Mean |
SD |
Min |
P25 |
Median |
P75 |
Max |
| NO2
mean |
56.22 |
19.14 |
19.95 |
45.29 |
54.67 |
67.54 |
121.59 |
| O3
mean (8hr) |
39.11 |
34.72 |
4.06 |
16.16 |
28.78 |
51.72 |
209.97 |
| SO2
mean |
17.72 |
11.72 |
2.62 |
9.25 |
14.89 |
23.56 |
90.25 |
| RSP
mean |
51.65 |
27.24 |
14.14 |
30.50 |
44.37 |
67.54 |
161.8 |
| Temp
mean |
20.79 |
5.71 |
5.37 |
17.21 |
20.55 |
25.30 |
29.80 |
| Temp
max |
23.52 |
5.81 |
6.60 |
20.07 |
23.45 |
27.70 |
33.20 |
| Temp
min |
18.59 |
5.94 |
4.18 |
14.30 |
18.06 |
23.80 |
28.30 |
| Hum
mean |
78.40 |
9.46 |
46.00 |
73.00 |
79.00 |
85.00 |
96.00 |
The
three-monthly mean of the daily concentrations of air
pollutants are shown in Tables 6 to 9. Levels are generally
higher in colder seasons for NO2 and RSP. A distinct
pattern is observed for O3, when levels in the last
quarter of each year are about twice those of the other
quarters. The levels of SO2, after reaching a peak in
the third quarter of 1994, show a steady decline throughout
1995 but increase slightly in 1996.
| Table
6 : |
3-monthly
mean, S.D. and range of daily SO2, 1994 - 1996 *
|
| Time
period |
No.
of observations |
Mean
|
S.D.
|
Min
|
Max
|
| Jan-Mar
94 |
90
|
20.23
|
10.22
|
2.75
|
48.93
|
| Apr-Jun
94 |
91
|
24.42
|
11.92
|
6.22
|
54.66
|
| Jul-Sep
94 |
92
|
25.63
|
15.53
|
6.69
|
68.49
|
| Oct-Dec
94 |
92
|
18.15
|
6.53
|
6.06
|
46.65
|
| Jan-Mar
95 |
90
|
20.83
|
11.65
|
8.57
|
64.14
|
| Apr-Jun
95 |
91
|
18.69
|
12.13
|
4.80
|
53.13
|
| Jul-Sep
95 |
90
|
17.60
|
10.44
|
4.67
|
51.98
|
| Oct-Dec
95 |
92
|
15.90
|
6.21
|
2.74
|
33.18
|
| 1994
- 1995 |
728
|
20.18
|
11.35
|
2.74
|
68.49
|
| Jan-Mar
96 |
91
|
17.32
|
11.10
|
2.62
|
55.46
|
| Apr-Jun
96 |
91
|
18.11
|
12.35
|
5.26
|
90.25
|
*
first half-year
| Table
7: |
3-monthly
mean, S.D. and range of daily NO2, 1994 -1996 *
|
| Time
period |
No.
of observations |
Mean
|
S.D.
|
Min
|
Max
|
| Jan-Mar
94 |
90
|
63.52
|
17.29
|
32.93
|
111.44
|
| Apr-Jun
94 |
91
|
44.94
|
16.69
|
19.43
|
97.11
|
| Jul-Sep
94 |
92
|
45.70
|
19.71
|
18.94
|
105.11
|
| Oct-Dec
94 |
92
|
60.05
|
15.50
|
38.43
|
111.05
|
| Jan-Mar
95 |
90
|
61.94
|
16.64
|
35.04
|
122.44
|
| Apr-Jun
95 |
91
|
46.29
|
16.15
|
21.68
|
101.49
|
| Jul-Sep
95 |
92
|
43.03
|
15.21
|
16.41
|
91.98
|
| Oct-Dec
95 |
92
|
64.14
|
16.10
|
19.82
|
98.09
|
| 1994
- 1995 |
730
|
53.67
|
18.83
|
16.41
|
122.44
|
| Jan-Mar
96 |
91
|
63.60
|
18.05
|
29.37
|
121.59
|
| Apr-Jun
96 |
91
|
48.85
|
17.36
|
19.95
|
118.39
|
*
first half-year
| Table
8 : |
3-monthly
mean, S.D. and range of daily RSP, 1994 -1996 *
|
| Time
period |
No.
of observations |
Mean
|
S.D.
|
Min
|
Max
|
| Jan-Mar
94 |
84
|
60.69
|
26.20
|
16.91
|
142.82
|
| Apr-Jun
94 |
91
|
35.91
|
13.60
|
16.27
|
90.45
|
| Jul-Sep
94 |
91
|
40.72
|
21.23
|
17.13
|
101.47
|
| Oct-Dec
94 |
92
|
56.41
|
20.82
|
14.96
|
105.93
|
| Jan-Mar
95 |
90
|
58.16
|
22.69
|
18.62
|
159.73
|
| Apr-Jun
95 |
91
|
41.33
|
18.18
|
19.45
|
112.20
|
| Jul-Sep
95 |
92
|
37.06
|
17.29
|
14.77
|
94.91
|
| Oct-Dec
95 |
92
|
71.38
|
26.01
|
19.59
|
142.37
|
| 1994
- 1995 |
723
|
50.12
|
24.33
|
14.77
|
159.73
|
| Jan-Mar
96 |
91
|
60.37
|
27.49
|
14.14
|
119.98
|
| Apr-Jun
96 |
91
|
42.92
|
24.15
|
19.41
|
161.81
|
*
first half-year
| Table
9: |
3-monthly
mean, S.D. and range of daily O3, 1994 -1996 * |
| Time
period |
No. of observations
|
Mean
|
S.D.
|
Min
|
Max
|
| Jan-Mar
94 |
90
|
27.16
|
18.77
|
1.94
|
94.31
|
| Apr-Jun
94 |
90
|
22.06
|
18.30
|
2.23
|
81.31
|
| Jul-Sep
94 |
92
|
22.80
|
21.21
|
1.38
|
129.94
|
| Oct-Dec
94 |
87
|
40.48
|
22.42
|
0
|
88.81
|
| Jan-Mar
95 |
90
|
24.51
|
18.22
|
0.31
|
65.54
|
| Apr-Jun
95 |
91
|
22.03
|
15.09
|
0
|
61.38
|
| Jul-Sep
95 |
90
|
24.60
|
18.31
|
0.06
|
76.88
|
| Oct-Dec
95 |
92
|
46.08
|
17.97
|
4.75
|
100.06
|
| 1994
- 1995 |
722
|
28.69
|
20.70
|
0
|
129.94
|
| Jan-Mar
96 |
89
|
36.98
|
27.78
|
4.56
|
172.96
|
| Apr-Jun
96 |
91
|
41.19
|
40.42
|
4.06
|
209.97
|
first
half-year
|
| |
|
| 5.2
|
Time
Trends of Air Pollutants
The
time trends of individual air pollutants for 1994 -
95 and 1996 (first half-year) are shown in Figures 1
- 4 and 1a - 4a respectively. For NO2 and RSP, a distinct
cyclical pattern with a long wavelength is observed,
and higher levels in winter. For O3 and SO2, shorter
wavelengths are seen, with peaks in early spring and
late autumn for the former and mid-summer for the latter.
There is no obvious increasing trend for all four pollutants
during the 1994 - 94 period. Levels of O3 are generally
higher in the first half of 1996 compared to 1994 -
95.
|
View Graphs:
- Figure
1: Daily mean levels of nitrogen dioxide from January 1,
1994 to December 31,1995 (Average of seven monitoring stations)
- Figure
1a: Daily mean levels of nitrogen dioxide from January 1
to June 30, 1996 (Average of seven monitoring stations)
- Figure
2: Daily mean levels of respirable suspended particulars
from January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1995 (Average of five
monitoring station)
- Figure
2a: Daily mean levels of respirable suspended particulars
from January 1 to June 30, 1996 (Average of five monitoring
station)
- Figure
3: 8-hour mean levels of ozone from January 1, 1994 to December
31, 1995 (Average of two station)
- Figure
3a: 8-hour mean levels of ozone from January 1 to June 30,
1996 (Average of two station)
- Figure
4: Daily mean levels of sulphur dioxide from January 1,1994
to December 31, 1995 (Average of six station)
- Figure
4a: Daily mean levels of sulphur dioxide from January 1
to June 30, 1996 (Average of six station)
| 5.3
|
Summary
Statistics of Hospital Admissions
Summary
statistics of daily counts of hospital admissions for
respiratory and circulatory diseases in 1994 and 1995,
and in the first half of 1996 are shown in Tables 10
and 10a respectively. The daily mean numbers of admissions
in 1996 (first half-year) was generally higher than
those in 1994 to 1995 (by 32% for respiratory diseases,
20% for cardiovascular diseases and 27% for both combined).
| Table
10: |
Summary
statistics of daily hospital admissions for respiratory
and cardiovascular diseases (1994-95) |
|
Mean |
SD |
Min |
P25 |
Median |
P75 |
Max |
| Total
* |
235.83 |
39.05 |
151 |
207 |
233 |
259 |
383 |
| Respiratory |
134.44 |
24.89 |
84 |
116.75 |
131 |
150 |
232 |
| Cardiovascular |
101.39 |
20.57 |
54 |
87 |
101 |
116 |
177 |
| Asthma |
22.22 |
7.84 |
6 |
16 |
21 |
27 |
51 |
| AMI** |
4.05 |
2.61 |
0 |
2 |
4 |
6 |
14 |
*
Total = Respiratory diseases + Cardiovascular diseases
**
Acute myocardial infarction
| Table
10a: |
Summary
statistics of daily hospital admissions for respiratory
and cardiovascular diseases (1996, first half-year)
|
|
Mean |
SD |
Min |
P25 |
Median |
P75 |
Max |
| Total
* |
298.53 |
49.44 |
192 |
261.75 |
295.5 |
331.25 |
427 |
| Respiratory |
177.14 |
30.54 |
108 |
152.75 |
176 |
201 |
251 |
| Cardiovascular |
121.39 |
28.76 |
61 |
101 |
122 |
140 |
200 |
*
Total = Respiratory diseases + Cardiovascular diseases
The
total numbers of admissions for 1994-95 by age and type
are shown in Table 10b. A total of 172,157 hospital
admissions for respiratory and cardiovascular (circulatory)
diseases were recorded in the selected hospitals during
the period 1994-95 and used in the Poisson regression
model while 171,829 were used (i.e., excluding 328 admissions
with no record of age) in the analysis by age group
| Table
10b: |
Number
of admissions due to respiratory and cardiovascular
diseases by hospital in 1994-95 |
Age
group
|
0 - 4 |
5 - 14 |
15 - 64 |
65+ |
unknown |
total |
| Cardiovascular
diseases |
420 |
438 |
22,871 |
50,116 |
169 |
74,014 |
| Respiratory
diseases |
30,263 |
9,864 |
20,229 |
37,628 |
159 |
98,143 |
| Both
diseases |
30,683 |
10,302 |
43,100 |
87,744 |
328 |
172,157 |
|
| |
|
| 5.4
|
Time
Trends of Hospital Admissions
Time trends of hospital admissions for respiratory and
cardiovascular diseases for the period 1994 - 1995 and
the first half of 1996 are shown in Figures 5 - 7 and
5a - 7a respectively. An increasing trend throughout
the overall study period is evident, with a cyclical
pattern more obvious in 1994. This was contributed largely
by respiratory diseases, with an approximately three-month
cyclical pattern, while hospital admissions for cardiovascular
diseases displayed a sinusoidal pattern with a longer
period. For the first half of 1996, the sinusoidal pattern
was less obvious (Fig. 5a - 7a).
|
View Graphs:
- Figure
5: Daily hospital admissions (respiratory and cardiovascular
diseases) from January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1995
- Figure
5a: Daily hospital admissions (respiratory and cardiovascular
diseases) from January 1 to June 30, 1996
- Figure
6: Daily hospital admissions (respiratory diseases) from
January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1995
- Figure
6a: Daily hospital admissions (respiratory diseases) from
January 1 to June 30, 1996
- Figure
7: Daily hospital admissions (cardiovascular diseases) from
January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1995
- Figure
7a: Daily hospital admissions (cardiovascular diseases)
from January 1 to June 30, 1996
| 5.5
|
Correlation
between Individual Air Pollutants, and between Air
Pollutants and Hospital Admissions
The
correlations between individual air pollutants from
1994 to 1995 and for each season are shown in Table
11. Overall, the correlation between NO2 and RSP was
good, while those between RSP and O3, NO2 and SO2, and
NO2 and O3 were fair. In general, the correlation between
pollutants was higher in summer, except between SO2,
and NO2, where the correlation coefficient was the highest
in winter. The high degree of collinearity between air
pollutants, in particular, NO2 and RSP cautions against
the use of a multiple pollutant model in the analysis.
| Table
11: |
Pearson
correlation coefficients between mean daily concentrations
of pollutants (1994-95) |
|
|
Summer
(Jun-Aug) |
Autumn
(Sep-Nov) |
Winter
(Dec-Feb) |
Total
|
|
| | | | | | |