TABLE OF CONTENTS

13.     ENvironmental Monitoring and Audit Requirements.. 13-1

13.1    Introduction. 13-1

13.2    Air Quality. 13-1

13.3    Noise. 13-1

13.4    Water Quality. 13-2

13.5    Waste Management Implication. 13-2

13.6    Land Contamination. 13-3

13.7    Terrestrial and Marine Ecology. 13-4

13.8    Fisheries. 13-6

13.9    Landscape and Visual 13-7

13.10  Cultural Heritage. 13-8

13.11  Hazard to Life. 13-8

 

List of Appendices

 

Appendix 13.1       Implementation Schedule of Recommended Mitigation Measures

 


13.                    ENvironmental Monitoring and Audit Requirements

13.1                 Introduction

13.1.1.1        This section provides a summary of the requirements of environmental monitoring and audit (EM&A) for the construction and operational phases of the Project and associated works based on the assessment results of the various environmental issues.  Details of the EM&A requirements are provided in a stand-alone EM&A Manual.

13.1.1.2        The purpose of the EM&A programme is to ascertain and verify the assumptions implicit to, and accuracy of, EIA study predictions.  The EM&A programme includes the scope of the EM&A requirements for the Project to ensure compliance with the EIA study recommendations and assess the effectiveness of the recommended mitigation measures.  The following sections summarise the recommended EM&A requirements with the Implementation Schedule of Recommended Mitigation Measures presented in Appendix 13.1.

13.2                 Air Quality

Construction Phase

13.2.1.1        EM&A for potential dust impact should be conducted during construction phase so as to check compliance with the legislative requirements.  Details of the monitoring and audit programme are contained in a stand-alone EM&A Manual.

13.2.1.2        Regular site audits for potential air quality impact are recommended to be conducted during the entire construction phase of the Project so as to ensure the implementation of the mitigation measures proposed in this EIA Report and the suppression measures stipulated in Air Pollution Control (Construction Dust) Regulation, the use of approved or exempted non-road mobile machinery stipulated in Air Pollution Control (Non-road Mobile Machinery) (Emission) Regulation, and the use of appropriate fuel stipulated in Air Pollution Control (Fuel Restriction) Regulation.

Operational Phase

13.2.1.3        No adverse impact would be anticipated during the operational phase of the Project.  No EM&A requirement would be required during the operation of the Project.

13.3                 Noise

Construction Phase

13.3.1.1        Noise monitoring is recommended as part of the EM&A programme for the construction phase of the Project to check compliance with the construction noise criteria. 

13.3.1.2        The implementation of the recommended mitigation measures for construction activities should also be audited as part of the EM&A programme, with reference to the latest implementation schedule in the Construction Noise Management Plan (CNMP) to be submitted and agreed with the Director of Environmental Protection (DEP).

Operational Phase

13.3.1.3        No adverse traffic noise impact is anticipated on existing NSRs and no committed and planned NSRs have been identified within the 300m assessment area at the time of EIA study. EM&A requirements are not considered necessary.

13.3.1.4        As no planned fixed noise sources would be proposed under the Project, no EM&A requirement is therefore deemed necessary.

13.4                 Water Quality

Construction Phase

13.4.1.1        With the implementation of good site practices, recommended mitigation measures and enhancement measures to control construction site runoff, no adverse water quality impact for land-based works is anticipated during the construction phase. Nevertheless, regular water quality impact monitoring for land-based works is required to ensure compliance with criteria as stipulated in EIAO-TM.

13.4.1.2        The potential water quality impact from the proposed marine works can be effectively controlled through the implementation of recommended mitigation measures (i.e., deployment of silt curtain).  Nevertheless, regular water quality impact monitoring for marine works is required to ensure compliance with criteria as stipulated in EIAO-TM.

13.4.1.3        Regular environmental site inspections at least once per week shall be carried out during construction phase to ensure that the recommended best management practices, mitigation measures and enhancement measures as recommended in this EIA Report and the EM&A Manual are properly implemented by the Contractor.

Operational Phase

13.4.1.4        The minor additional surface runoff will be collected and screened by road drainage system before diverting into the stormwater drains.  No water quality monitoring specifically for the operational phase of the Project is therefore required.

13.5                 Waste Management Implication

Construction Phase

13.5.1.1        During the construction period, it is the Contractor’s responsibility to ensure that all the waste produced during the construction of the Project are handled, stored and disposed of in accordance with good waste management practices, relevant legislation and waste management guidelines.

13.5.1.2        The Project Manager / Project Manager’s Representative and Independent Environmental Checker shall enforce the trip ticket system in accordance with paragraphs 25 and 21 of DEVB TC(W) No. 6/2010 respectively.

13.5.1.3        Waste materials generated during construction activities, such as construction and demolition (C&D) materials, are recommended to be audited at regular intervals to ensure that proper storage, transportation and disposal practices are implemented.  This measure ensures the proper disposal of waste.  The Contractor would be responsible for the implementation of any mitigation measures to minimise waste or mitigate problems arisen from waste materials.

13.5.1.4        A Waste Management Plan (WMP), as part of the Environmental Management Plan should be prepared in accordance with ETWB TC(W) No. 19/2005 and submitted to the Project Manager for approval.  The recommended mitigation measures should form the basis of the WMP.  The monitoring and auditing requirements stated in ETWB TC(W) No.19/2005 should be followed with regard to the management of C&D materials.

Operational Phase

13.5.1.5        It is expected that limited quantities of waste would be generated from the operation of the Project and adverse environmental impacts would not be anticipated with the implementation of good waste management practices.  Waste monitoring and audit programme for the operational phase of the Project is not required.

13.6                 Land Contamination

Construction Phase

13.6.1.1        Based on the site appraisal, three potentially contaminated sites (i.e. Public Carpark and Adjacent Vegetated Land (Site STW1), Dockyard (Site HUD1) and Sai Tso Wan Concrete Batching Plant (Site HUD2)) were identified with potential land contamination concerns to the Project.  However, it is considered not feasible to carry out the site investigation (SI) works under the EIA Study within the these potentially contaminated sites.  Moreover, there is an existing Vacant Land (Site LT2) which was inaccessible at the time of site walkover.  Based on the tentative construction programme, land clearance / resumption for the Project will not commence until 2026, there could be changes in the operation or land use within the three potentially contaminated sites and the inaccessible site which may cause further contamination issues.  Further site appraisal should be carried out within the Proposed Clearance Limit and off-site facilities / works areas at a later stage of the Project to confirm / update the land uses / activities and to identify the presence of on-site and off-site potential contamination sources.  In addition, should there be any expansion of the Proposed Clearance Limit, further site appraisal would also be required to be carried out within the expanded area. Contamination Assessment Plan(s) (CAP(s)) presenting the findings of the further site appraisal, the latest site conditions of the concerned sites and updated sampling strategy and testing protocol, should be submitted to EPD for approval.

13.6.1.2        The further site appraisal and submission of CAP(s) should be carried out prior to the commencement of the SI works.  The SI works should be carried out according to EPD’s approved CAP(s).  Following the completion of SI works and receipt of laboratory test results, Contamination Assessment Report(s) (CAR(s)) should be prepared to present the findings of the SI works and to discuss the presence, nature and extent of contamination.  If contamination is identified, Remediation Action Plan(s) (RAP(s)) which provides details of the remedial actions for the identified contaminated soil and / or groundwater should be endorsed by EPD.  The remedial actions should be formulated with consideration given to the Source-Pathway-Receptor Paradigm by adopting the appropriate control method(s) (i.e. source control method, pathway control method and/or receptor control method). To minimise the cost of remediation work, if remediation is required and where appropriate, “pathway control” approach, e.g. by proper capping the source of contamination by soil or concrete slabs or by the use of membranes or solidification, would be considered to prevent migration of contaminants.

13.6.1.3        Remediation action, if necessary, will be carried out according to EPD endorsed RAP(s) and Remediation Report(s) (RR(s)) will be submitted after completion of the remediation action.  The RR(s) should be endorsed by EPD prior to the commencement of construction works at the respective identified contaminated areas (if any). The submission of CAP(s), associated SI works and any necessary remediation should be carried out prior to the commencement of construction works. The EM&A requirements should be carried out in the form of monthly site inspection to ensure the recommended mitigation measures are properly implemented.

Operational Phase

13.6.1.4        No land contamination issue under operational phase is expected.

13.7                 Terrestrial and Marine Ecology

Construction Phase

13.7.1.1        Site clearance associated with construction works would potentially lead to the direct and indirect impacts on habitats and species of conservation importance.  Regular site audits and monitoring should be undertaken to implement good site practices and mitigation measures specified in S.8.11, as well as in other chapters in relation to noise, air quality, waste management and water quality control so as to alleviate the impact of construction disturbance on the ecology in the area. 

Preservation, Transplantation and/or Compensatory Planting of Flora Species of Conservation Importance

13.7.1.2        As described in S.8.11.3.7 – S.8.11.3.9, a pre-construction detailed vegetation survey should be conducted by qualified plant ecologist(s) prior to the commencement of site clearance and construction works in order to identify the presence of any individuals of flora species of conservation importance within the at-grade works area, including but not limited to Small Persimmon, Pitcher Plant, Pale Purple Eulophia, and any other flora species of conservation importance recorded in the literature review and the ecological survey.  The curriculum vitae of the qualified plant ecologist(s) and survey methodologies should be submitted to AFCD for review and approval beforehand. During the pre-construction detailed vegetation survey, each identified individuals should be tagged and mapped, with photographs and information including their height, diameter at breast height, spread, condition, form, amenity value, survival of transplantation and proposed treatment etc.  Prior to the commencement of transplantation, a Plant Preservation and Transplantation Proposal should be prepared and submitted to AFCD for approval.  The proposal shall include the findings of the pre-construction detailed vegetation survey, the proposed methodologies of plant preservation, transplantation and compensation, identification of suitable receptor site, implementation programme, post-transplantation monitoring and maintenance programme including monitoring frequency, monitoring parameters, and recommended remedial measures.  Mitigation approach in the order of in-situ preservation, transplantation, and compensation would be followed.  In the case where some directly affected individuals of Small Persimmon were deemed infeasible for preservation or transplantation, legitimate justifications shall be provided.  Compensation planting of the species could be considered and implemented.  The compensation ratio of affected individuals should be in the ratio of 1:1, unless agreed otherwise with AFCD.  The recommended compensation planting quantity, planting location, planting methodologies as well as provision of a post-planting monitoring programme should be included in the Plant Preservation and Transplantation Proposal.  A planting proposal shall be prepared for agreement with AFCD containing information on the recommended planting quantity, planting location, planting methodologies as well as provision of a post-planting monitoring programme.

Site Audit and Monitoring for Works Around Affected Watercourses and Waterbodies

13.7.1.3        Romer’s Tree Frog and Caridina serrata were recorded in the downstream sections of watercourses W2 and W3.  These habitats are sensitive to water quality deterioration from construction works planned in the upper tributaries. To mitigate these potential impacts, temporary stream diversions will be implemented to protect downstream fauna by maintaining water flow and preventing construction materials from entering the watercourses. For the marine works component, which includes dredging, marine DCM, and reclamation, silt curtains will be deployed around the periphery of the works area prior to commencement. This measure is designed to minimise the release of suspended solids from the seabed into the surrounding marine environment, thereby protecting marine water quality.

13.7.1.4        Regular site audits should be carried out to ensure best management of construction site run-off and discharge and mitigation measures proposed for reducing construction site run-off and discharge are being implemented with stringent adherence to relevant guidelines stipulated in the ProPECC PN 2/23 Construction Site Drainage (EPD, 2023) and ETWB TC(W) No. 5/2005 Protection of Natural Streams/Rivers from Adverse Impacts Arising from Construction Works (ETWB, 2005), which should include those listed in S.5.8.1, S.8.11.3.18 and S. 8.11.3.19.

Translocation of Romer’s Tree Frog or Other Identified Aquatic/Water-dependent Species of Conservation Importance

13.7.1.5        A pre-construction survey should be carried out by qualified ecologist(s) in the at-grade works area where direct impact would be anticipated in order to identify the presence of any individuals of Romer’s Tree Frog or any other aquatic/water-dependent species of conservation importance (inc. amphibians and freshwater fauna).  Greater caution should be paid to affected watercourses (i.e. W1, W2 and W3) and its adjacent riparian shrubland / grassland habitats.  The scope and methodology of the pre-construction survey, and the curriculum vitae of the qualified ecologist(s) should be submitted and agreed with AFCD prior to commencement of survey works.  In instances where individuals are identified in the works area and translocation is required, the methodology and findings of the pre-construction survey, along with a translocation and post-translocation monitoring plan presenting the number of individuals to be translocated, the translocation methodology, the identified translocation site, the implementation schedule, as well as post-translocation monitoring methodology and programme should be defined and presented in a Translocation Proposal, which shall be submitted to AFCD for comments and approval prior to translocation works.  Individuals should be translocated to nearby habitats of similar habitat conditions, adequate barriers such as hoarding and fencing should be set up around the works area following translocation to prevent individuals from entering the works area.  The potential translocation recipient site should be located well outside the areas where direct and indirect impacts from the construction works of the project (i.e. W5 and W6), as well as those of other planned/committed projects nearby, are not expected.

Translocation of Affected Coral Colonies

13.7.1.6        A pre-construction detailed coral survey shall be conducted in the marine works area prior to the commencement of marine works by qualified coral ecologist(s) with SCUBA diving qualification and experience, the curriculum vitae of whom shall be submitted to AFCD along with the scope and methodology of the detailed coral survey for review and agreement prior to commencement of the survey.  The survey should confirm specifically the number, the species and the location of coral colonies to be directly affected by the construction of the pile-supported VIPS, the reclamation and associated dredging works.  Identified coral colonies should be numbered, sized, photographed, mapped and tagged in the survey.  An assessment of the suitability of translocation for each identified coral colony should be presented in the coral translocation plan, along with the proposed recipient site, translocation methodology and programme, monitoring methodology and programme for the translocation coral colonies.  The potential translocation recipient site should possess a coral colony composition similar to that of the existing site and should be located well outside areas where direct and indirect impacts from the marine works of the Project, as well as of other planned/committed projects nearby, are not expected.  The findings of the detailed coral survey and the proposed treatment for the identified coral colonies should be reported in the Coral Translocation Proposal and submitted to AFCD for approval prior to commencement of the translocation works. 

Enhancement Opportunities on Seawall and Marine Structures

13.7.1.7        As recommended in S.8.11.4, several strategies could be integrated into the design of future coastal structures, such as seawalls on the reclaimed land for TYLL anchorages and towers, as well as surfaces and supporting structures on the pile-supported VIPS.  Following the confirmation of the final layout and design of these structures, a detailed Eco-shoreline Design Proposal shall be prepared and submitted to AFCD for agreement and approval. This proposal must include a comprehensive Ecological Monitoring Plan to establish a practical and feasible program for assessing the effectiveness of the design. The plan will detail the proposed monitoring methodologies, such as the use of standard marine ecological survey techniques, and define the performance parameters to be tracked. These parameters may include species diversity and abundance, recruitment rates of benthic organisms, and the health of key habitat-forming species, all of which will be proposed for AFCD's approval. The monitoring shall commence following the establishment of the eco-shoreline and the proposed monitoring period and frequency shall be agreed upon with AFCD.   A key component of the plan will be an adaptive management framework, which requires establishing clear performance criteria (i.e., action and limit levels). If monitoring reveals that these criteria are not being met, an investigation into the causes will be required, followed by the submission of a remedial action proposal to AFCD for approval. All monitoring and assessment work shall be conducted by qualified marine biologists with a minimum of five years of experience in marine organism identification and ecological restoration.

Operational Phase

13.7.1.8        No significant ecological impact is anticipated during the operational phase of the Project, as such no ecological monitoring and auditing during operational phase is required.

13.8                 Fisheries

Construction Phase

13.8.1.1        With the implementation of water quality mitigation measures during construction and operational phases, no adverse impact on fisheries is anticipated, thus fisheries-specific monitoring is considered not necessary.  Water quality monitoring should be undertaken in monitoring stations between the project area and fisheries sensitive receivers such as Ma Wan Fish Culture Zone to avoid any deterioration of water quality due to the construction works. 

Operational Phase

13.8.1.2        No adverse impact on fisheries is anticipated during the operational phase, thus fisheries-specific monitoring is considered not necessary.

13.9                 Landscape and Visual

13.9.1.1        The EIA has recommended landscape and visual mitigation measures to be undertaken during construction and operational phases of the Project.  The design, implementation and maintenance of landscape and visual mitigation measures should be checked to ensure that they are fully realized and that potential conflicts between the proposed landscape measures and any other project works and operation requirements are resolved at the earliest possible date and without compromise to the intention of the mitigation.

13.9.1.2        All mitigation measures proposed in the EIA and implemented by the Contractor should be audited by Registered Landscape Architect (RLA), as a member of the Environmental Team, on a regular basis to ensure compliance with the intended aims of the measures. The mitigation measures proposed should be embodied into the detailed engineering design and landscape design drawings and contract document. Site inspection should be undertaken monthly throughout the construction period. In particular, the extent of the agreed works areas should be regularly checked during the construction phase. The landscape auditor should audit the proposed mitigation measures in the EIA to ensure that they are fully implemented during construction and the 12-month establishment period during operational phase.

Construction Phase

13.9.1.3        Both the temporary and permanent works would cause direct impact on the landscape resources during construction phase, mainly the vegetation identified within both natural and man-made slopes (i.e. LR1.1 - Hillside Vegetation of Ma Wan and Tsing Yi, LR1.2 - Vegetation on Engineered Slope at Northwest Tsing Yi Interchange, LR2.1 - Hillside Vegetation at North Lantau and LR2.2 - Vegetation on Engineered Slope along North Lantau Highway), natural shoreline of the south of Ma Wan (i.e. LR1.3 – Sandy Beach along the coastal area of Ma Wan and LR1.4 – Natural Rocky Shore along the coastal area of Ma Wan and Tsing Yi) and north of Lantau Island (i.e. LR 2.3 – Natural Rocky Shore facing of Kap Shui Mun), developed area of Tsing Yi (i.e. LR1.6) and watercourses at North Lantau (i.e. LR2.7).  Mitigation measures such as tree preservation and transplantation, provision of decorative screen hoarding, reinstatement of affected landscape area shall be checked to ensure that they are incorporated in the detailed design.  Implementation of the applicable recommended mitigation measures shall be monitored through the site audit programme during the construction phase.

Operational Phase

13.9.1.4        To mitigate the landscape and visual impacts caused by the proposed works during operational phase, mitigation measures listed in Appendix 13.1 shall be implemented as appropriate.  Specific EM&A during operational phase of the Project is not required as long as the proposed mitigation measures in the EIA and as depicted in the Landscape Mitigation Plan are fully implemented.

13.10              Cultural Heritage

Construction Phase

13.10.1.1    For built heritage, no EM&A would be required.

13.10.1.2    For terrestrial archaeology, no EM&A would be required.  As a precautionary measure and pursuant to the Antiquities and Monuments Ordinance (Cap. 53), the project proponent is required to inform AMO immediately in case of discovery of antiquities or supposed antiquities in the course of works, so that appropriate mitigation measures, if needed, can be timely formulated and implemented in agreement with and to the satisfaction of AMO.

13.10.1.3    For marine archaeology, no EM&A would be required.   As a precautionary measure and pursuant to the Antiquities and Monuments Ordinance (Cap. 53), the project proponent is required to inform AMO immediately in case of discovery of antiquities or supposed antiquities in the course of construction of the works, so that appropriate mitigation measures, if needed, can be timely formulated and implemented in agreement with and to the satisfaction of AMO.

Operational Phase

13.10.1.4    No impact on terrestrial archaeology, built heritage, and marine archaeology would be anticipated during the operational phase of the Project.  Hence, mitigation measures as well as impact monitoring and audit are not required.

13.11              Hazard to Life

Construction Phase

13.11.1.1    For the potential risks associated with the 2 PHIs, good safety practices are recommended to further manage and minimise the potential risks during the construction phase of the Project.  Regular audits during the construction phase are recommended.

13.11.1.2    Blasting activities regarding on-site transport and use of explosives should be supervised and audited by competent site staff to ensure strict compliance with the blasting permit conditions.

Operational Phase

13.11.1.3    The risk imposed by the Project is considered negligible during operational phase and thus monitoring and audit are not required.