TABLE OF CONTENTS

14.      SUMMARY OF ENVIRONMENTAL OUTCOMES.. 14-1

14.1    Overview.. 14-1

14.2    Environmental Benefits of the Project 14-1

14.3    Incorporation of Environmentally Friendly Options. 14-1

14.4    Environmental Design Recommended. 14-4

14.5    Key Environmental Problems Avoided and Environmentally Sensitive Areas Protected. 14-5

14.6    Environmental Protection Measures Recommended. 14-6

14.7    Estimation of Population Protected. 14-16

 

List of Tables

Table 14.1        Summary of Key Environmental Problems Avoided and Sensitive Areas Protected

Table 14.2        Key Recommended Mitigation Measures and any Associated Benefits

 

 


14.                        SUMMARY OF ENVIRONMENTAL OUTCOMES

14.1                     Overview

14.1.1.1            Section 2 outlines the details and benefits of the Project together with the consideration of alternatives during the investigation study stage, which has taken into account the findings of various engineering and environmental review.  The technical assessments in Sections 3 to 12 have demonstrated that all the statutory requirements in EIA Study Brief (ESB No. 359/2023) and EIAO-TM have been compiled with.

14.1.1.2            This chapter summarises the key environmental outcomes arising from this EIA study, the approaches that have been adopted to either avoid or minimise various environmental impacts throughout the design process, and the associated environmental enhancements and mitigation measures.

14.2                     Environmental Benefits of the Project

14.2.1.1            The existing major roads such as Tuen Mun Road and Lantau Link would experience traffic congestion during peak hours.  The Project would ameliorate the traffic conditions on these major roads and reduce the potential air quality and noise impacts to the neighbouring sensitive receivers.

14.2.1.2            Furthermore, eco-shoreline features would also be incorporated on newly established coastal structures and shorelines.  It is expected that these features will facilitate the recruitment, settlement and colonisation of marine benthos, thereby enhancing the overall quality and diversity of associated marine ecosystems in the vicinity.

14.3                     Incorporation of Environmentally Friendly Options

14.3.1.1            Avoidance of environmental impacts is one of the main considerations throughout evaluation and development of alignment options.  In case the environmental impacts could not be completely avoided due to limitation of actual site situations, environmentally friendly alternatives or designs were taken for compliance with relevant EIA requirements, subject to actual site condition/engineering design.  The following approaches to avoid environmental impacts have been suitably incorporated into the layout of the Recommended Alignment:

·       Minimisation of extensive retaining structures on existing geotechnical features at Tsing Yi;

·       Avoidance of reclamation at North Lantau shoreline;

·       Minimisation of reclamation and dredging extents for the reclamation in Ma Wan and Tsing Yi;

·       Minimisation of slope cutting;

·       Avoidance of direct impact to ecological sensitive area;

·       Minimisation of habitat loss; and

·       Incorporation of eco-shoreline features on newly established coastal structures and shorelines.

Minimisation of retaining structures on existing geotechnical features at Tsing Yi

14.3.1.2            The alignment has been refined by incorporating a connection viaduct into Tsing Sha Highway, at same time providing a direct connection from Cheung Tsing Tunnel westbound to TYLL westbound.   The recommended alignment is adopted to reduce the length of retaining structures by approximately 115m on existing geotechnical features, as well as reduce the numbers of affected existing geotechnical features, such as the man-made slope and the extension of retaining wall.  With the omission of the TYRW-TYLL Viaduct connection that require land adjacent to Sai Tso Wan Road, the land resumption are greatly reduced and the number of affected air and noise sensitive receivers is reduced.  By adopting this alignment design, it would also minimise the landscape and visual impacts at the Tsing Yi Connection.

Avoidance of Reclamation at North Lantau Shoreline

14.3.1.3            To protect the deflection pier at North Lantau, pile-supported Vessels Impact Protection System (VIPS) is proposed to be adopted in the area of existing shoreline.  The VIPS structure will be supported by bored piles with a superstructure and hanger slab to protect the pier from vessel impact, thus reclamation is no longer required at North Lantau.  The short-term nature of the piling activities is expected to cause minimal disturbance to surrounding marine fish and fisheries-sensitive receivers.

14.3.1.4            The avoidance of reclamation at North Lantau benefit the preservation of the intertidal zone and ecosystem along the shoreline, including six species of conservation importance at the intertidal zone, a majority being locally very common shorebirds, such as Great Egret, Pacific Reef Heron, White-throated Kingfisher etc. Moreover, the surfaces of supporting structures for the pile-supported VIPS present new opportunities for the recruitment, settlement and colonisation of marine benthos, thereby enhancing the overall quality of associated marine ecosystems in the vicinity.

Minimisation of Reclamation and Dredging Extents for the Reclamation in Ma Wan and Tsing Yi

14.3.1.5            Marine anchorages in Ma Wan are combined into a single common anchorage.  This approach reduces the material required for anchorage construction and minimises excavation work.  As a result, both the environmental impact of material excavation and disturbances to the marine environment are reduced.  Furthermore, the combination of anchorages can reduce the overall area of Ma Wan reclamation.

14.3.1.6            This reduction of reclamation area has reduced the total amount of dredged sediments, hence reducing the associated water quality impacts during the construction phase.  The extent of channel narrowing at both MWF KSMF are also reduced, hence reducing the change in hydrodynamic regime under operational phase.

14.3.1.7            In consideration of the different reclamation methods, different reclamation approaches from dredging to non-dredging were investigated.  Subject to actual site condition, it is proposed that non-dredging method using DCM should be applied to reduce the long-term settlement of the reclamation and limit the construction time required that reducing the potential environmental impact from dredging works.  Under the current reclamation scheme, the amount of dredged sediment would be reduced by about 32,840m3.  This would minimise the waste management implications and secondary environmental impacts from the marine traffic induced from the disposal of marine sediment.

14.3.1.8            Combined with the adoption of the VIPS, the total reclamation area in the current scheme (about 19.8 hectares) is reduced by about 4.1 hectares (17%) when compared with the original scheme in the Project Profile (about 23.9 hectares).

Minimisation of Slope Cutting

14.3.1.9            The Project alignment connects Route 11, North Lantau Highway, HKIW-NEL Link and then pass through hilly terrains in North Lantau to Tsing Yi.  Measures in the alignment design to minimising slope cutting have been considered and adopted in order to (i) minimise disruption and impacts to the landscape resources and characters, (ii) minimise the number of trees impacted, (iii) minimise potential impacts to the natural habitats and the associated ecology, and (iv) minimise the amount of excavation spoil and construction waste generated.   Total generated C&D materials including slope cutting has been reduced by 42% comparing with the design scheme under previous feasibility study stage of the Project.

14.3.1.10         The Recommended Alignment of Lantau landing point is shifted northwards, thus enabling the slope cutting location of the North Lantau Interchange to shift eastwards towards a lower terrain.  The modification of the alignment also minimise the substantial slope cutting along the northeast face of Fa Peng Teng. These design modifications substantially preserve the natural features of the area, reduce the volume of excavated materials as well as the associated construction dust impacts.

14.3.1.11         At the Tsing Yi Connection, with the omission of the TYRW-TYLL Viaduct, the length of retaining structures on existing geotechnical features (see also Section 2.11.2) is minimised as the need for clearance of land adjacent to Sai Tso Wan Road is no longer required.  Furthermore, the anchorage of main bridge at Tsing Yi side has been further reviewed to avoid direct impact to the adjacent Cheung Tsing Highway structure by shift the anchorage westwards, allowing the anchorage sit at the toe of the existing slope.  This refinement not only minimised the constructability difficulty on existing slope and avoid direct impact to the adjacent highway structure but also minimise the landscape and visual impact at Tsing Yi side.

Avoidance of Direct Impact to Ecological Sensitive Area

14.3.1.12         The Recommended Alignment and its works footprint were thoroughly considered, evaluated and selected from several alternative alignment options proposed in previous stage studies (S.2.7 refers).  This process has resulted in the current alignment option, which aims to avoid potential direct and indirect impacts on recognised sites of conservation importance and other ecologically sensitive areas, such as the Ma Wan Egretry and Night Roost located on the Project's northern side.

Minimisation of Habitat Loss

14.3.1.13         The Recommended Alignment was tailored to minimise encroachment into natural habitats and ecological resources of high ecological importance, resulting in a final optimised layout that would result in no loss of any natural terrestrial habitats in Tsing Yi.  Due to engineering constraints posed by the site conditions and the inherent requirements to connect TYLL with other planned roads and highways, areas of natural terrestrial habitats in North Lantau, including shrubland / grassland, watercourse and intertidal zone, would be inevitably impacted. 

14.3.1.14         To minimise the extent of habitat loss and its impact on the ecology in this area, the proportion and extent of slope works and at-grade roads were minimised and strategically positioned along existing developed area.  Some road sections in North Lantau have opted for tunnel or viaduct form to minimise the footprint of at-grade works and to avoid ecological impact, i.e. the viaduct section at Yi Chuen and tunnel connecting HKIW-NEL Link, which avoid impact on concerned watercourse.

14.4                     Environmental Design Recommended

14.4.1.1            Other than the initiatives to avoid environmental impacts as summarised in Section 14.3, further efforts have been exercised to minimise impacts.  The need for environmental designs required to mitigate the associated impacts have also been identified and will be implemented, as appropriate.  A summary of these approaches is given below:

·       Adoption of environmentally friendly construction method;

·       Implementation of trip-ticket system;

·       Implementation of environmental monitoring and audit system; and

·       Incorporation of eco-shoreline features on newly established coastal structures and shorelines

Adoption of Environmentally Friendly Construction Method

14.4.1.2            Subject to actual site condition/engineering design, precast construction method would be adopted, with bridge deck formed from precast concrete sections manufactured off-site and assembled together on-site, which minimise the extent and duration of construction activities required on-site and hence the potential environmental impacts in the vicinity during construction.  Other construction methods would be considered only when precast construction method is not feasible.

Implementation of Trip-Ticket System

14.4.1.3            In order to monitor, document and verify the disposal of C&D materials at landfills and public fill reception facilities, and to control fly tipping, a trip-ticket system for disposal of C&D materials would be implemented.

Implementation of Environmental Monitoring and Auditing System

14.4.1.4            In addition to the mitigation measures as described above (see more details in the Implementation Schedule of Recommended Mitigation Measures as given in Appendix 13.1), a comprehensive environmental monitoring and auditing programme would be implemented to cover various aspects of concerns.  An Independent Environmental Checker would also be employed to ensure that all the necessary mitigation measures are implemented in a timely and orderly manner.

Incorporation of Eco-shoreline Features on Newly Established Coastal Structures and Shorelines

14.4.1.5            Newly established coastal structures (approx. 1.4 km of artificial shoreline), such as vertical seawalls, riprap/sloping seawalls, surfaces of supporting structures on the reclaimed land for TYLL anchorages and towers and for the pile-supported VIPS, present new opportunities for the recruitment, settlement and colonisation of marine benthos, thereby enhancing the overall quality of associated marine ecosystems in the vicinity.  These include the consideration of the use of natural building materials, such as granite boulders or irregular shaped dolosse as building blocks, incorporation of elements that diversify microhabitats and enhance the quality of settlement substrates such as the eco-tiles or 3D-printed terracotta settlement plates with features like indents, pits, pools, crevices, meanders and cracks, and opt for a wavy shoreline as opposed to a straight one, could all help enhance structural diversity and diversify microhabitats in these marine systems, thereby enhancing the quality of these habitats.

14.5                     Key Environmental Problems Avoided and Environmentally Sensitive Areas Protected

14.5.1.1            Sections 14.3 and 14.4 have summarised the key approaches adopted in the current proposal to avoid, minimise and mitigate environmental impacts.  Some of these approaches have contributed to avoid a number of environmental problems and protect a number of environmentally sensitive areas.  Table 14.1 presents the key environmental problems avoided and sensitive areas protected by these approaches.

Table 14.1     Summary of Key Environmental Problems Avoided and Sensitive Areas Protected

Design Approach

Environmental Problems Avoided and Sensitive Areas Protected

Optimised the alignment

 

·    The current alignment avoided direct impact on residential development at Ma Wan and indirect impact on Ma Wan Egrety, as well as direct or indirect impacts on Tung Lung Chau Lighthouse which is a declared monument.

Adoption of environmentally friendly construction methods

·    Adoption of off-site precast structures / modular integrated construction method to minimise the impacts on air quality, noise, water quality and waste during construction.

Minimisation of extensive retaining structures on existing geotechnical features at Tsing Yi

·    The refined alignment design reduced slope works and land resumption at Tsing Yi;

·    No. of affected air and noise sensitive receivers have been reduced; and

·    The landscape and visual impacts at the Tsing Yi Connection has been minimised.

Avoidance of reclamation at North Lantau Shoreline

 

·    The avoidance of reclamation at North Lantau would benefit the preservation of the intertidal zone and ecosystem along the shoreline, including six species of conservation importance at the intertidal zone.

Minimisation of reclamation and dredging extents for the reclamation in Ma Wan and Tsing Yi;

·    The total amount for dredged sediments has been reduced, hence reducing the associated water quality impacts during construction phase

·    The extent of channel narrowing at both MWF and KSMF has been reduced, hence reducing the change in hydrodynamic regime under operation phase.

·    The total reclamation area has been reduced by about 17 %.

Minimisation of slope cutting

 

·    Minimised disruption to the landscape resources and characters

·    Minimised potential impacts to the natural habitats and associated ecology

·    Minimised the amount excavation spoil and construction waste generation

Avoidance of direct impact to ecological sensitive area

·    The current alignment avoided potential direct and indirect impacts on recognised sites of conservation importance and other ecologically sensitive areas, such as the Ma Wan Egretry and Night Roost located on the Project's northern side

Minimisation of Habitat Loss

·    To minimise the extent of habitat loss and its impact on the ecology in this area, the proportion and extent of slope works and at-grade roads were minimised and strategically positioned along existing developed area. 

·    Some road sections in North Lantau have opted for tunnel or viaduct form to minimise the footprint of at-grade works and to avoid ecological impact, i.e. the viaduct section at Yi Chuen and tunnel connecting HKIW-NEL Link, which avoid impact on concerned watercourse.

Avoidance of illegal dumping

 

·    The recommended preventive measures would avoid / minimise the chance of illegal dumping.

Implementation of Environmental Monitoring and Auditing System

 

·    Ensure all the recommended measures are properly in place and their effectiveness.

 

14.6                     Environmental Protection Measures Recommended

14.6.1.1            Mitigation measures have been recommended to further reduce the environmental impacts during construction and operational phases of the Project. Key recommended mitigation measures and any associated benefits are summarised in below Table 14.2.

Table 14.2     Key Recommended Mitigation Measures and any Associated Benefits

Environmental Aspect

Key Recommended Mitigation Measures

Associated Benefits

Air Quality Impact

Construction Phase:

·     Implementation of control measures as required in the Air Pollution Control (Construction Dust) Regulation to minimise construction air quality impact.

·     The approved non-road mobile machinery (NRMMs) under NRMM Regulation (excluding exempted NRMMs) would be used on-site and NRMMs supplied with mains electricity instead of diesel-powered should be adopted as far as possible to minimise the potential emission from NRMMs.

·     Barging points provided with Tipping hall enclosed by 3-side screen with top and water spraying and flexible dust curtains to minimise dust dispersions.

·     Controlled loading of dredged materials and covering of dredged materials to avoid potential odour emission

·     Any odorous materials shall be transported away from the Project site within 24 hours to minimise odour impact.

 

Operational Phase:

·     No mitigation measures would be required.

·     Protect Air Sensitive Receivers (ASRs) by reducing air pollutants generation and emissions.

·     Ensure compliance with the requirements in Annex 4 of the EIAO-TM at the ASRs

 

Noise Impact

Construction Phase:

·     Implementation of quality and quieter powered mechanical equipment (PME), temporary / movable noise barriers and enclosure to screen off noise from relatively statie PMEs, quieter construction methods, acoustic tunnel door or enclosure at the tunnel portal as well as good site practices during construction phase of the Project to miminise construction noise impact.

·     For village houses / temporary structure with residential use at North Lantau which are close to the construction sites, it is recommended to install site hoarding with higher surface density and height to provide extra noise attenuation to protect these NSRs.

·     Submission of Construction Noise Management Plan (CNMP) before tendering.

 

Operational Phase:

·     Implementation of Low Noise Road Surfacing (Refer to Figure 4.5 for locations and extents) to alleviate road traffic noise impact on surrounding NSRs.

·     Protect Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) by reducing construction and road traffic noise impacts.

·     Ensure compliance with the respective road traffic noise requirements at neighbouring NSRs.

 

Water Quality Impact

Construction Phase:

·     ProPECC PN 2/24 - Construction Site Drainage should be followed to minimise construction run-off.

·     Deployment of silt curtain throughout the reclamation works area to minimise dispersion of suspended solid/sediment during construction/dredging.

·     ETWB TC (W) No. 5/2005 - Protection of Natural Streams / Rivers from Adverse Impacts Arising from Construction Works should be adopted to minimise the water quality impacts on any natural streams or surface water systems.

 

Operational Phase:

·     The design of site drainage and disposal of various site effluents should follow the relevant guidelines and practices as given in the ProPECC PN 1/23 to minimise water quality impact.

·     Best Management Practices for storm water discharge are recommended to reduce the stormwater pollution arising from the Project.

·     Protect the neighbouring Water Sensitive Recivers (WSRs) during construction and operational phases.

Waste Management Implications

·     Implementation of good site practices and waste reduction measures (e.g. reuse of C&D materials before off-site disposal or develop a materials recovery and recycling programme during construction and operation) to minimise waste generation.

·     A Construction and Demolition Material Management Plan should be prepared in accordance with Section 4.1.3 “Construction and Demolition Materials” of the Project Administration Handbook for Civil Engineering Works (PAH).

·     Preparation of a Waste Management Plan, as part of the Environmental Management Plan thus minimising waste generation and ensuring proper disposal and treatment of waste materials.

·     Implement a trip-ticket system for each works contract in accordance with DEVB TC(W) No. 6/2010 to ensure that the disposal of C&D materials is properly documented and verified.

·     Handling of chemical waste in accordance with the Code of Practice on the Packaging, Labelling and Storage of Chemical Wastes, and disposal of chemical waste at licensed chemical waste recycling / treatment facilities so that chemical waste can be properly handling.

·     General refuse should be stored in enclosed bins or compaction units separately from C&D materials to minimise hygiene issues.

·     An enclosed and covered area is preferred to reduce the occurrence of wind-blown light materials.

·     The recyclable component of general refuse, such as aluminium cans, paper and cleansed plastic containers shall be separated from other wastes for ease of handling.

·     Provision and collection of recycling bins for different types of recyclable waste shall be set up by the Contractor.  The Contractor shall also be responsible for arranging recycling companies to collect these materials.

·     Conduct regular inspection, monitoring, collection and disposal of floating refuse by the Contractor

·     The Contractor shall carry out an education programme for workers in avoiding, reducing, reusing and recycling of materials generation.  Posters and leaflets advising on the use of the bins shall also be provided in the sites as reminders.

·     The Contractor is encouraged to deliver waste materials to EcoPark and Y·PARK for reuse and recycling, especially for yard wastes during slope works and tunnel works at North Lantau thus reducing disposal volume to landfill.

·     On-site reuse of Category L sediment generated (e.g. as backfilling materials) to minimise marine dumping of sediment.

·     For off-site disposal of sediments, follow the basic requirements and procedures specified under paragraph 4.2.1 of Chapter 4 of the PAH.

·     For the purpose of site allocation and application of marine dumping permit and if considered necessary by EPD, separate Sediment Sampling and Testing Plan(s) (SSTP) shall be submitted to EPD for agreement under Dumping at Sea Ordinance (DASO).

·     Additional GI works, based on the SSTP, shall be carried out in order to confirm the disposal arrangements of the excavated/dredged sediment and submitted to EPD for agreement under DASO. Sediment Quality Report(s) (SQR), reporting the chemical and biological screening results and the estimated quantities of sediment under different disposal options, shall then be submitted to EPD for agreement under DASO.

·     Stockpiling of contaminated sediments should be avoided.  If temporary stockpiling of contaminated sediments is necessary, the excavated / dredged sediment should be covered by tarpaulin and the area should be placed within earth bunds or sandbags to prevent leachate from entering the ground, nearby drains and surrounding water bodies.  The stockpiling areas should be completely paved or covered by linings in order to avoid contamination to underlying soil or groundwater.

·     In order to minimise the potential odour / dust emissions during excavation / dredging and transportation of the sediment, the excavated / dredged sediments shall be wetted for the whole processing and shall be properly covered when placed on trucks or barges.  Loading of the excavated / dredged sediment to the barge shall be controlled to avoid splashing and overflowing of the sediment slurry to the surrounding water.

·     To avoid illegal dumping, all dumping vessels have to be approved in a marine dumping permit issued under DASO.

·     In case Type 3 – Special Treatment / Disposal sediment were identified in the additional sampling works, the Project Proponent shall be responsible for identifying and agreeing with the Director of Environmental Protection the most appropriate treatment and/or disposal arrangement for the Type 3 sediment as required in the PAH. A possible disposal arrangement for Type 3 sediment is by geosynthetic containment.

·     Minimise waste generation.

·     Ensure proper handling of chemical waste.

·     Ensure the C&D materials are disposed of and delivered to designated sites.

·     Ensure proper waste management, treatment and reuse of excavated / dredged sediment.

 

Land Contamination

·     Subject to the finding of Contamination Assessment Plan(s) / further site appraisal and Contamination Assessment Report (CAR), if contamination is identified, the remediation measures for remediation works as stated in Remediation Action Plan(s) should be implemented to ensure soil / groundwater contamination, if any, would be identified and properly remediated prior to construction works.

·     Land contamination issues could be resolved before commencement of construction works.

Ecology

Permanent and Temporary Loss of Terrestrial and Marine Habitats

·     Localising at-grade works to habitats with lower ecological value (e.g. developed area, plantation), and opting for tunnel and viaduct sections to reduce permanent loss of natural habitats.

·     Optimising the land required for temporary works to necessary minimum to minimise temporary loss of natural habitats.

·     Work avoidance at the upper tributary and box culvert installation at the section coinciding with at-grade road section to minimise the extent of permanent loss and to retain waterflow at watercourse W2.

·     Reduce the length and elevation level / profile of tunnel to avoid and minimise the extent of loss of watercourse W3.

·     Where no actual construction works are required, vegetation clearance along watercourses would be avoided, adoption of work exclusion zone and elevated temporary works planform atop watercourses should be implemented to avoid and minimise impact on watercourse.

·     Opting for pile-supported VIPs at North Lantau to minimise overall reclamation extent as reclamation at Yi Chuen is avoided.

 

Species of Conservation Importance with Low Mobility and Restricted Niche

·     Conduct detailed pre-construction survey to identify individuals to be affected by works and carry out in-situ preservation, transplantation / translocation or compensation planting where appropriate to avoid and minimise direct impact on plant, coral and amphibian species of conservation importance.

 

Habitat Fragmentation, Wildlife Movement and Injuries or Mortalities due to Roadkill and Collision

·     Implementation of construction phasing and habitat reinstatement following completion of temporary works to minimise the impact of habitat fragmentation and wildlife movement impediment.

·     Incorporation of fencing, u-shaped channels, hedge planting of dense vegetation to prevent access to and guide wildlife away from the at-grade road structures and lead them towards the passageways under the viaduct sections to minimise the likelihood of wildlife injuries and mortalities due to roadkill and collision.

 

Disturbance and Water Quality-related Impacts

·     Implementation of precautionary measures and good site practice to minimise construction disturbance on adjacent habitats, species of conservation importance and associated flora and fauna.

·     Temporary stream diversion to retain waterflow and avoid run-off of construction materials into watercourses in accordance with guidelines specified in ETWB TC(W) No. 5/2005 Protection of Natural Streams/Rivers from Adverse Impacts Arising from Construction Works.

·     Implementation of water quality specific mitigation measures recommended in the water quality impact assessment and best management practices as stipulated in ProPECC PN 2/23 Construction Site Drainage and ETWB TC(W) No. 5/2005 Protection of Natural Streams/Rivers from Adverse Impacts Arising from Construction Works to reduce the impact of water quality deterioration due to run-off, discharge and reclamation on waterbodies and aquatic-associated species.

·     Deployment of silt curtains during reclamation and other marine works to minimise the indirect impact of sedimentation and runoff on marine ecology.

 

Diversion and Modification of Affected Watercourses

·     North-branching upper tributary of W2 would be preserved at its headwater, while the section intercepting with the at-grade road section would be replaced a box culvert in order to retain water flow in the watercourse.

·     Watercourse W1 and section of W3 would be diverted and replaced by modified watercourse of similar nature, with incorporation of natural elements in the design.  Guidelines specified in ETWB TC(W) No. 5/2005 should be followed.  Stream diversion proposal for the W1, W2 and W3 would be submitted to AFCD for comment prior to the commencement of works.

 

Enhancement Opportunities on Seawall and Marine Structures

·     The use of natural building materials such as granite boulders or irregular shaped dolosse as building blocks for riprap and sloping seawalls is recommended. The rough textures and gaps between the stacked building blocks would provide suitable conditions for benthos settlement and provide sheltering habitats for marine wildlife.

·     Incorporation of elements that diversify microhabitats and enhance the quality of settlement substrates such as the eco-tiles or 3D-printed terracotta settlement plates with features like indents, pits, pools, crevices, meanders and cracks should also be considered on vertical seawalls or surfaces to encourage recruitment and settlement of corals and other benthos.

·     Incorporating a wavy design instead of a straight shoreline for the coastal structures could enhance structural diversity and create varying light penetration gradients in microhabitats which warrants further exploration if feasible.

·     Where practical, recycling of dismantled concrete-based or steel-based building materials e.g. roadblocks, culverts, steel rebars as artificial reef structures could also be considered in suitable areas away from the main navigation channel.

·     Following the confirmation of the final layout and design of created coastal structures, a proposal on eco-shoreline design shall be prepared and submitted to AFCD for agreement and approval.

·     Minimise the direct and indirect impacts to the habitat and species of conservation importance during construction phase and operational phases.

·     Minimising physical disturbance to the surrounding habitats.

·     Reduce temporary / permanent losses of natural habitats

·     Avoid / minimise impact on concerned watercourses

·     Enhancing the quality of newly created habitats through diversifying micro-habitats and creating suitable settlement and sheltering habitats for wildlife

Fisheries

·     Non-dredged reclamation methods, including DCM and jet grouting for ground treatment, will be adopted whenever practicable to reduce the release of suspended solids and contaminants into water bodies.

·     Implementation of water quality mitigation measures during the construction phase, which shall cover marine-based site investigation works, marine-based foundation works, above-water construction works, site run-off from general site operation, and accidental spillage of chemicals and sewage from workforce that minimising fisheries impact.

·     Minimise the direct and indirect finishers impact during construction and operational phases.

Landscape and Visual

Construction Phase:

·     Trees without impact from the proposed works should be retained and any existing trees unavoidably affected by the works should be transplanted as far as possible in accordance with DEVB TC(W) No. 4/2020 - Tree Preservation.

·     Erection of decorative screen hoarding with advance planting or hoarding compatible with the surrounding setting to alleviate the landscape impact to surrounding public viewers.

·     Construction facilities and activities on work sites and areas should be carefully managed and controlled, including height and disposition / arrangement to minimise any potential adverse landscape impacts.

·     Reinstatement of the temporarily affected landscaped area within assessment area in like-for-like basis to restore the existing natural environment as far as possible.

Operational Phase:

·     Aesthetically pleasing design as regard to the form, material and finishes should be incorporated into bridges, ancillary buildings and other associated engineering facilities so as to blend in the structures with the adjacent landscape and visual context.

·     Buffer screen planting, including shrubs, to provide screening for the proposed structures if space is available.

·     As far as practicable, compensatory tree planting requirement of 1:1 in terms of number in accordance with DEVB TC(W) No. 4/2020 for compensation of felled trees subject to the availability of space and agreement made with relevant departmental parties.

·     Landscape treatments on slope or retaining structure in accordance with GEO Publication No. 1/2011 – Technical Guidelines on Landscape Treatment for Slopes shall be adopted subject to the availability of space and agreement with relevant departmental parties to maximise the greenery provision and alleviate the visual impact due to the loss of vegetation.

·     Minimise landscape and visual impacts during construction and operational phases.

Impact on Cultural Heritage

·     No direct or indirect impact is anticipated on the built heritage identified. No mitigation measures would be required.

·     No impact on terrestrial and marine archaeology are anticipated during the construction and operational phases.  As a precautionary measure and pursuant to the Antiquities and Monuments Ordinance (Cap. 53), the project proponent is required to inform AMO immediately in case of discovery of antiquities or supposed antiquities in the course of works, so that appropriate mitigation measures, if needed, can be timely formulated and implemented in agreement with and to the satisfaction of AMO.

·     Verify the presence of any archaeological remains and identify measures if necessary prior to construction

Hazard to Life

Construction Phase:

·     Implement the following “Good Practices” to limit the number of causalities and/or fatalities during construction phase of the project due to risk associated with Potentially Hazardous Installations (PHIs):

-     Establishment of emergency response / evacuation plans;

-     Safety / emergency response training and drills for all personnel; and

-     Maintain the number of construction workers on-site to a minimum.

·     Implement the following recommendations to prevent risks due to flying objects, rollover of lifting vehicles and falling of heavy construction material during lifting activities during construction phase of the project:

-     Shielding provision such as mesh fencing to be installed along the slip road between the proposed works areas and the terminal; and

-     Risk assessment should be undertaken and method statement with lifting plan should be formulated by the Contractor prior commencement of lifting works.

·     Implement the following recommendations to minimise potential risks due to on-site transport of explosives:

-     Emergency plan should be developed to address uncontrolled fire during transport. Case of fire near an explosive carrying vehicle in jammed traffic should be included in the plan. Activation of fuel and battery isolation switches on vehicle when fire breaks out should also be included in the emergency plan to reduce likelihood of prolonged fire leading to explosion;

-     Working guideline should be developed to define procedure for explosives transport during adverse weather such as thunderstorm;

-     Detonators should be transported separately from other Class 1 explosives. Separation of vehicles should also be maintained through the trip;

-     Develop procedure to ensure the availability of parking space on site for the explosives carrying vehicle. Delivery should not be commenced if parking space on site is not secured;

-     Hot work should be suspended during passage of the diesel vehicle truck and bulk emulsion truck in the tunnels;

-     Speed limit for the diesel vehicle truck and bulk emulsion truck in the tunnels should be imposed. The truck may be escorted while underground to ensure route is clear from hazards and obstructions;

-     Fire screen should be used between cabin and the load on the vehicle;

-     Lining should be provided within the transportation box on the vehicle;

-     Ensure packaging of detonators remains intact until handed over at blasting site;

-     Ensure that cartridged emulsion packages are not damaged before every trip; and

-     Use experienced driver with good safety record.

·     Implement the following recommendations for the safe use of explosives:

-     Blast charge weight should be within the maximum MIC as specified for the given blast face;

-     Temporary mitigation measures such as blast doors or heavy duty blast curtains should be installed at the portals at suitable locations underground to prevent flyrock and control the air overpressure;

-     Secure refuge areas to workers within the construction sites should be identified for their temporary shelter during blasting;

-     A Chief Shotfirer and a Blasting Engineer shall be employed in addition to the normal blasting personnel to ensure that the works are safe and coordinated between blasting areas;

-     Shotfirer to be provided with a lightning detector, and appropriate control measures should be in place;

-     A boulder survey should be undertaken based on the likely PPV values that would result from the blasting process.  Those boulders subject to the vibration higher than the allowable limit should be strengthened, removed, or constructed with boulder fence, prior to the commencement of blasting;

-     Establishment of no-blast zones for areas of high sensitivity/risk;

-     The surface blasting benches will be covered with blasting cages, blast mats and blasting screens to limit flyrock potential;

-     All hiking paths/ footpaths located within the 200m assessment area will be temporarily closed during blasting/ explosives delivery from the barging point to the blasting sites;

-     Drill bits larger than 64mm should not be brought to the sites to avoid drilling a larger blasthole by accident; and

-     The Contractor will place warning signs at the concerned area (i.e. Yi Chuen) to let the residents know the blasting schedule of the surface blasting site S01 so that they have to be evacuated or stay indoor away from windows. Before the commencement of blasting, the contractor will also strike a gong to alert the residents and notify the residents in person to ensure all potentially affected personnel are fully aware of the surface blasting.

·     Limit the number of causalities and /or fatalities during construction phase due to risk associated with the two PHIs at Tsing Yi.

 

·     Protect nearby sensitive receivers from adverse impacts due to transportation, and use of explosive for blasting.

General

·     Implement a comprehensive Environmental Monitoring System throughout the entire construction period.

·     Employ an Environmental Team (ET) and Independent Environmental Checker (IEC)

·     Ensure compliance with all statutory requirements and those recommendations in the EIA report

14.7                     Estimation of Population Protected

14.7.1.1                  Population and environmental sensitive areas in the vicinity of the Project site have been protected through the avoidance and/or minimisation of environmental impacts from the construction and operation the Project. The alignment of TYLL has been avoided passing through Ma Wan so that minimising air quality impact, noise impact and visual impacts on residential dwellings at Ma Wan including Park Island and Ma Wan villages during both construction and operational phases.  Besides, the exclusion of Tsing Yi Road West Connection Viaduct has also minimised the impacts on air and noise sensitive receivers at Tsing Yi side.