TABLE OF CONTENTS
2.1 Project
Site Location and Site History
2.3 Appreciation
of Existing Environment
2.4 Description
of the Project
2.5 Project
Benefits and Environmental Initiatives
2.6 Formulation
of the Recommended Outline Development Plan
2.7 Consideration
of Alternatives and Development of the Preferred Option.
2.8 Key
Environmental Outcomes
2.9 Development
Programme for Project
2.10 Major
Concurrent Projects
List of tables
Table 2.1 .... Land
Use Budget of the RODP
Table
2.3 .... Comparison
of Benefits and Dis-benefits for the Configuration Options for NTMDC
Table
2.4 .... Comparison
of Benefits and Dis-benefits of Options of Site Formation Works
Table
2.6 .... Preliminary
Construction and Population Intake Schedule
Table
2.7....... Summary
of Potential Cumulative Impacts from Major Concurrent Projects
LISTS OF FIGURES
|
Recommended
Outline Development Plan |
|
|
Road Network of the
Project |
|
|
General Layout of New
District Distributor Roads |
|
|
Location Plan of
Designated Project 2 (DP2) ¨C Revitalisation of Ngau Tam Mei Drainage Channel
and River Diversion Works |
|
|
Locations of Major
Concurrent Projects |
LIST OF
Appendices
|
Preliminary
Construction Phasing and Population Intake Schedule |
|
|
Tentative
Construction Programme |
(a) rural settlements
(e.g. Yau Tam Mei Tsuen) with mostly temporary domestic structures;
(b) Ngau Tam Mei
Drainage Channel (NTMDC) which dissects the Project Site, flowing east to west towards Deep Bay
via Kam Tin River;
(c) scattered brownfield
operations, such as logistics and freight operation, open storage,
vehicle-related operation and warehouse / workshop;
(d) farmland and
fishponds scattered along the existing NTMDC and a chicken farm in the
southeastern part of the Project Site; and
(e) two permitted burial
grounds (PBGs) (i.e. PBG Nos. YL/16 and 17) on the green knolls in the western
part of the Project Site, as well as some scattered graves located outside PBGs but
within the Project Site, including a grave of a prominent local figure at the
area off Chuk Yau Road. Though none
of the graves are declared monuments and graded historical buildings (Section
12 refers).
(a) Two existing chicken farms, a LBF and NTM AWCP are
located to the southeast and southwest of the Project Site. Besides, a sewage
treatment plant within TMB directly borders the northern boundary of the NTM
NDA. The proposed developments under the Project need to comply with the
relevant requirements to minimise potential odour impacts
from these facilities/uses.
(b) The firing range of TMB is considered as a potential
fixed noise source to the proposed noise sensitive uses in the northern part of
the Project.
(c) The NTMDC connects the pond habitat upstream, with the Deep
Bay wetland habitats to the west of the assessment area of the Project. It
serves as a bird flight path for various waterbird species. This channel also plays a role in flood
management for the surrounding low-lying area. For minimising
the environmental impacts, the Project should manage run-off and water quality,
maintain habitat connectivity, and minimise potential
disturbances to bird flight paths.
Currently, the operation of NTMDC is governed by Environmental Permit
No. FEP-01/003/1998/A held by Drainage Services Department (DSD) covering
drainage channel from Ngau Tam Mei to Kam Tin River near Tai San Wai.
(a) The existing
major distributor roads including San Tin Highway, Ngau Tam Mei Road, Chuk Yau
Road, San Tam Road, Castle Peak Road ¨C Tam Mi will likely pose air quality
and road traffic noise impacts to the proposed developments in the western part
of the Project Site.
(b) The existing High Speed Rail (formerly known as Express Rail Link) runs
underneath and through the Project Site in southeast-northwest orientation. The
future NOL Main Line also traverses the Project Site, and the associated NTM
Depot (NTD) is anticipated to pose development constraints and potential noise
impacts to the developments of the Project.
(c) The existing
overhead electricity transmission lines with pylons are located to the south
and east of the Project which require sufficient vertical and horizontal
separation distances from adjacent proposed land uses in accordance with the
requirements stated in Hong Kong Planning Standards and Guidelines (HKPSG).
(d) The
development of the NOL Main Line, including the planned NTM Station and
associated railway depot within the Project Site, is being undertaken by the
MTRCL separately. The railway scheme, including land area, and layout of the
NTM Station, railway depot, and ancillary facilities was gazetted on 6 October
2023 and authorised on 8 April 2025. The potential interfacing challenges may
arise concerning land use integration, infrastructure alignment, and
construction sequencing between the railway facilities and the NTM NDA, and
thus there should be close coordination to minimise the interface issues.
Table 2.1 Land Use Budget of the RODP
|
Land Use |
Approximate Area (ha) |
|
Government,
Institution and Community (GIC) Facilities (including the UniTown, Integrated Hospital, other GIC Facilities and
Reserve) |
66 |
|
Residential (including railway topside commercial /
residential development) |
19 |
|
Open Space |
13 |
|
Roads and Other Uses (including Railway and
Amenity) |
29 |
|
Green Belt (including
permitted burial grounds) |
3 |
|
Total: |
130 |
¡¤
Fire Station and Ambulance Depot cum Staff Quarters;
¡¤
Community Recycling Centre;
¡¤
Primary School
and Secondary School;
¡¤
Refuse Collection Points (RCPs);
¡¤
Electricity Substations (ESSs); and
¡¤
Sewage Pumping Station (SPS).
¡¤
DD roads ¨C Road D1 and its slip roads connecting to San Tin Highway;
¡¤
LD roads ¨C Road L1, Road L2, Road L3, and the
proposed road connection to/from STT; and
¡¤
Upgrade of
existing roads to LD roads ¨C Chuk Yau Road,
Ngau Tam Mei Road and San Tam Road.
¡¤
Sewerage network
and the proposed supporting infrastructure (Section 2.4.4.8 refers);
¡¤
Freshwater
system; and
¡¤
Other utilities such
as power supply, telecommunication, internet and wireless communication
service, street lighting, etc.
¡¤
Section of Road D1
including its slip roads connecting to San Tin Highway;
¡¤
Section of Road L1, Road
L2 and Road L3 which cross NTMDC; and
¡¤
Section of proposed road
connection to/from STT.
¡¤
Item 1 ¨C An urban development or redevelopment
project covering an area of more than 50 ha.
¡¤
Northern Metropolis Synergy
¨C With the vision to develop
NM into a ¡°New International I&T City¡±, NMAA outlines the strategic
positioning and development themes of the four major zones in NM. Amongst them, the I&T Zone covers
STT and NTM. STT will be the hub
for clustered I&T development and the core of industry development of the
entire NM. It is also proposed that
land be reserved in NTM for use of post-secondary education institutions, with
a focus on scientific research, to complement the I&T development in STT,
promoting ¡°research, academic and industry¡± collaboration. Through leveraging physical
and functional connections with STT, the future planning of NTM NDA should aim
to capture the synergistic and interactive relationship with STT and the other
major development areas in NM, with a view towards fostering integration
between the two NDAs within the I&T Zone and NM.
¡¤
Nurture and
Attract Talent ¨C To complement the positioning of NTM NDA as an
Academic and Research District, a worker- and student-friendly university town
vibe will be developed to groom high-calibre talents to support I&T
development in STT, tie in with the Government¡¯s objective of building Hong
Kong into an international post-secondary education hub. The planning and urban design of the NDA
should target to facilitate knowledge exchanges and cultivation of innovative
ideas. On the other hand, a
comprehensive residential neighbourhood with commercial, leisure and GIC
facilities should be planned to foster a quality living environment for
residents and talents. This would
in turn attract and nurture talent to provide manpower for supporting
industrial development. Housing mix
of the NDA should complement the positioning of NTM NDA as an Academic and
Research District.
¡¤
Versatile
Community ¨C To create a liveable area for
the future population for NTM NDA as well as supporting the wider developments
in NM, an integrated community with adequate and quality urban services and
community facilities would be provided in NTM NDA to support the territorial
housing demand with an emphasis on ¡°live, learn, play and work¡±. To optimise the
strategic location in NTM NDA, a large portion of land is reserved for the UniTown. Other
key district facilities including healthcare and other supporting GIC
facilities are also planned to serve NTM NDA and the wider communities. A residential neighbourhood with
comprehensive amenities and supporting facilities is planned around the future
NTM Station, to enable the residents to reach the GIC facilities for daily
necessities, open space and major transport facilities by walking or
cycling. A wide range of community
facilities are also planned in NTM NDA to develop the area as a vibrant and
liveable community to attract and retain global academics and researchers.
¡¤
Meet Long-term
Housing Needs of Hong Kong ¨C The Project will provide about 12,600-13,800 new flats, including private housing and
dedicated rehousing estate (DRE) to meet long-term housing needs of Hong
Kong. Also, student hostels and
staff quarters in the UniTown, and government
departmental quarters will be provided.
¡¤
Home-job Balance
to Reduce Cross-district Commuting ¨C Through a mix of educational, healthcare, commercial, community
and government land uses, the Project will
generate approximately 26,000 new jobs. To complement the positioning of NTM
NDA as an Academic and Research District, predominantly private housing will be
provided in the area, which can enrich the choices of accommodation for
teaching / research and hospital staff, reducing the need for cross-district
commuting and improving home-job balance.
¡¤
Multi-functional Blue-green Spine ¨C The current NTMDC will be
revitalised, and the riverfront will be integrated with blue-green
infrastructure to reduce flood risks and enhance environmental sustainability.
Leisure and recreational uses will be integrated to create pleasant and
engaging public spaces. The blue-green spine will also form a key east-west
transit corridor incorporated with pedestrian walkways and cycling tracks
across the entire NDA that enhances connectivity within the urban fabric and
facilitates social interactions.
¡¤
Provision of GIC
Facilities ¨C The Project has proposed a wide range of GIC
facilities to support both existing and planned local population, as well as
regional and territorial demand on specific aspects. The proposed GIC
facilities include educational, recreational and healthcare facilities such as
the Integrated Hospital.
¡¤
Enhance Land
Efficiency and Rural Environment ¨C At present,
there are about 22 ha of brownfields clustered in the Project Site, including logistics and freight operation, open storage, vehicle-related
operation and warehouse/ workshop, etc., which produce adverse environmental, traffic and visual impacts to the neighbourhood. With the proposed
developments and infrastructures, land use efficiency would be enhanced and the overall environment in the area can be significantly improved.
¡¤
Improve Sewerage
System Provision ¨C The Project will
improve the existing sewerage
infrastructure with new sewerage
networks and a new SPS which would benefit both the population of the nearby
existing residential development / villages and the proposed developments
under the Project. Water quality would
be improved by the introduction of new sewerage networks to the currently unsewered
areas.
¡¤
Improve Transport
Connectivity and Community Services to the Existing Villages and Residential
Development in the Vicinity of NTM ¨C Existing villages
and residential developments can be benefited from the newly planned GIC facilities, open space and improved rail-and-road transport connectivity, and
other infrastructure services brought by the Project. These enhancements
provide collective benefit and contribute to improve
the quality of life of the existing villages and residential
developments in the vicinity of the Project.
¡¤
Improve
Stormwater Management and Climate Resistance ¨C The proposed
revitalised NTMDC and retention tanks would mitigate potential flooding issue
and enhance the overall stormwater management system. By increasing the channel¡¯s capacity and
naturalizing its flow through ecological design features, the revitalised NTMDC
not only enhance its ecological function but also effectively convey stormwater run-off while
reducing peak flow rates. The proposed retention tanks serve as critical flood
attenuation facilities, temporarily storing excess stormwater during heavy
rainfall events to prevent downstream flooding. The improved stormwater
management also enhances climate resilience by better handling intense rainfall
and extreme weather, reducing flood risks and increasing the area¡¯s
adaptability to climate change.
¡¤
Revitalisation of the NTMDC ¨C By integrating sustainability principles with engineering, Hong Kong¡¯s
completed river revitalisation projects[1] demonstrate how infrastructure can simultaneously
achieve environmental and social objectives - bringing life back to the city¡¯s
waterways and setting a benchmark for urban ecological design. Upon completion of revitalisation works
at previously concrete lined drainage channels, river ecosystems can be
restored, and biodiversity will be enhanced through the promotion of wildlife
growth. The revitalised rivers
serve to reconnect urban communities with nature. Post-revitalisation surveys1
have recorded a resurgence of native species (including bird, fish and dragonfly
species) which indicate the improvement in the ecological health of these
waterways. Similar
to Hong Kong¡¯s earlier successful river revitalisation initiatives, the treatments for the NTMDC including channel widening, flattening of the
southern riverbank, as well as incorporating green and eco-conservation
elements, such as planting a variety of vegetation and mimicking natural stream
environments, are proposed for the revitalisation of NTMDC. The slopes of NTMDC will be transformed into planting areas,
and new plantings including riparian species would be introduced to enhance
aquatic habitats and support the implementation of blue-green infrastructure.
The planting of native vegetation and creation of wildlife environments will
also maximise biodiversity and promote environmental sustainability. These treatments
would bring positive impacts to the nature, as well as
the future population of NTM, whereby the overall ecological value and biodiversity would increase.
It is expected that the enhanced habitats could provide more ecological
resources for the waterbirds species of conservation
importance, such as Citrine Wagtail, Great Egret, Little Egret and
White-throated Kingfisher. The details of the revitalisation features and
ecological enhancement measures will be further developed following Drainage
Services Department Practice Note No. 3/2021 Guidelines
on Design for Revitalisation of River Channel, and design elements will be
agreed with relevant parties and departments during detailed design stage.
¡¤
Integrated
Walkability, Cycling, and Open Space Network ¨C The Project promotes sustainable, low-carbon
mobility and active lifestyles through a comprehensive, people-centered network of pedestrian walkways and cycle tracks.
This network connects key destinations ¨C including UniTown,
Integrated Hospital, public transport hubs, residential neighbourhood,
retail outlets and community facilities ¨C via elevated, covered, and
barrier-free routes. The open space provision meet the
enhanced provision of 3.5 m2 per person under Hong Kong 2030+. The robust cycling
network integrates with existing tracks, including connections to the New
Territories Cycle Track Network along Castle Peak Road and an arterial route
connecting major activity nodes across the NTM NDA.
¡¤
Preservation of Points of Local Historical Interests ¨C Preservation of points of local historical interests has been considered
in the RODP, taking into account the public comments obtained during the public
engagement exercise (PE) (Table 2.2 refers), to
promote cultural sustainability. Notably, Wai Cheung Ancestral Hall (WCAH) is
proposed to be preserved in situ allowing flexibility for future adaptive use
within a planned open space. The open space surrounding WCAH could be utilised
for public to interact, relax and hold local community events. Subject to the
detailed design in later stage, the former Yau Tam Mei Primary School, valued
for its social significance, as a sole source of education in Yau Tam Mei
Tsuen connecting many descendants of the village, and possesses some historical
value as an embodiment of various acts of local benevolence recorded throughout
its history, is also proposed
to be preserved in situ within UniTown for potential
adaptive reuse. This could provide the future students/teaching staff with a
tangible link to the educational past of NTM. It is worth to note that both
buildings are neither declared monument nor graded historic building, and their
preservation, conservation and protection is not required under EIAO-TM.
Table 2.2 Key
Comments Related to Environment Received During Statutory Public Inspection Period and PE Period
|
Key
Issue |
Public
Comments |
Responses |
|
Air Quality |
The cumulative air quality impacts should
be assessed, and effective mitigation measures should be formulated to control
air pollution. Polluting industrial/commercial activities should be forbidden
in order not to worsen the air quality. |
No polluting industrial/commercial
activities are proposed within the Project Site. |
|
Odour arising from the LBF and air quality impact arising from other pollution
sources should be addressed to protect the interests of the community. |
•
Odour and air
quality impact from pollution sources have been assessed. •
Details of air quality
(including odour) impact assessment are provided in Section 3 of
this EIA Report. |
|
|
Water Quality |
Any untreated surface run-off generated from the Project Site during both construction and operational phases should be
prevented from discharging into NTMDC or its tributaries, other natural or
man-made channels, stormwater drainage and wetlands directly. |
Proper drainage and sewerage systems with
due consideration of avoidance and minimization of the potential water
quality impacts will be adopted. Details of water quality
impact assessment are provided in Section 5 of this EIA
Report. |
|
Watercourses with natural substrates and good water quality should not be
destroyed and should be well protected. |
It is anticipated that removal of a few
watercourses is unavoidable for site formation works under the Project.
Nevertheless, NTMDC will be revitalised to bring
positive impacts to the nature in NDA. |
|
|
Waste Management |
Storage, transportation
and disposal of solid wastes should be under stricter monitoring and control
to avoid any fly-tipping of solid wastes generated
from the Project. |
•
Global
Positioning System (GPS) or equivalent system for tracking and monitoring of
all dump trucks will be engaged to record their travel routings and parking
locations for avoiding illegal dumping and landfilling. •
Trip Ticket System will be
implemented to avoid illegal dumping. |
|
Ecology |
Given the high ecological sensitiveness around the Project Site, year-long ecological surveys for diverse taxa groups and habitats
should be conducted in the EIA study. Additional bird survey efforts should
be invested during the migratory seasons to assess the ecological impacts on
migratory birds. |
A 12-month baseline ecological survey
(including bird survey) was conducted. Details of baseline ecological data and impact assessment are
provided in Section 9 of this EIA Report.
|
|
Eurasian Otter (Lutra
lutra) could utilise
the existing NTMDC and fishponds nearby. Intensive active search for field
signs of Otters and the approach of employing Local Ecological Knowledge by
conducting questionnaire interviews with local people should be taken. |
There are no official published data or records of the Otter in the
Project Site, and no Eurasian Otter was recorded during the baseline
ecological survey. Further
additional interview targeting the sightings of the Otter among the local
people in NTM area was conducted upon receipt of the public comment. Based on the interview findings, no
sightings of the Otter in NTM area were reported or heard by interviewees. |
|
|
Alternative alignment of the proposed road
connection to/from STT should be explored to minimise
woodland loss. |
The alignment of the proposed road connection to/from STT has been
reviewed and optimised with respect to engineering feasibility and other
considerations to minimise the loss of woodland habitat. |
|
|
Removal of trees and
vegetation in the Project Site should be avoided as far as possible in order to
reduce ecological impact, loss of habitats and urban heat island effect. Any
vegetation loss in the Project should be compensated through the cultivation
of native plant species. |
• It is anticipated that some trees and
vegetation removal are unavoidable for site formation works. Nevertheless,
the land use formulation has maximised the
opportunity for open space with greening in order to
reduce ecological impact including the loss of habitats as well as landscape
impact. •
Tree compensation is proposed to be provided at a 1:1 tree
compensatory ratio at the roadside amenity areas and open space to compensate
for tree loss due to the Project as far as practicable. Areas within the
Project Site and off-site areas for compensatory tree planting would be
explored and negotiated with relevant project proponent(s) to achieve 1:1
ratio in compensatory tree planting number as far as practicable. |
|
|
Avoidance / minimization of
both direct and indirect impacts on wetland within/adjacent to Wetland Buffer
Area (WBA) should be explored in both construction and operational phases. |
The Project has been carefully planned such that the works would only be situated
at the existing developed area / wasteland habitat within WBA to avoid
direct impact to wetland within/adjacent to WBA, and the modified watercourse
within WBA would be retained. |
|
|
Off-site negative impact,
such as construction noise during construction phase and human activities
during operational phase, would adversely affect foraging behavior ardeids at
NTMDC. |
• Construction Noise Management Plan will
be prepared during pre-tender and pre-construction stages to formulate the
requirement of mitigation measures, monitoring and audit programme.
• Mitigation measures, such as provision of non-building area
and ¡°Open Space¡± along both sides of NTMDC and peripheral tree planting as screening, have been adopted to minimise the indirect
impacts to ardeids
during operational phase. |
|
|
Impact on Agricultural Land and Fishponds |
Agricultural land in NTM
is generally in low degree of fragmentation which should be protected. Rural life and associated farmland and
fishponds should be preserved in NDA developments under the concept of urban-rural
integration to minimise impacts on local fisheries
and agricultural industries. |
Currently, the agricultural land in NTM
is scattered and mostly consists of abandoned farmland, which is assessed to
have low to moderate ecological value. To maximise
the utilisation of land resources, these scattered
plots of agricultural land are consolidated for developing into a functional
community providing land for a UniTown, Integrated
Hospital and residential neighbourhood to
complement with the I&T development in STT. That said, opportunities of
introducing urban farming in the planned open space are allowed under the
RODP. |
|
Cultural Heritage |
Direct and
indirect impacts on cultural heritage items should be identified. |
Direct and indirect impacts on the
identified cultural heritage items have been assessed in Section 12 of this EIA Report. |
|
Alternatives
should be further explored to avoid/minimise direct
loss on the cultural heritage items identified in both
construction and operational phases. |
Alternatives have been explored to avoid
direct loss on WCAH such that it would be preserved in situ. |
|
|
Existing buildings with
collective memories and heritage characters should be reserved to enrich the
continuity of heritage. |
Flexibility for potential adaptive reuse
of building structures of the former Yau Tam Mei Primary School by future
project proponents of UniTown is allowed in the
RODP. |
|
|
Contingency measures should be prepared in case items of
historical or archaeological importance can be spotted within the development
area during construction phase. |
In accordance with the Antiquities and
Monuments Ordinance (Cap. 53), Antiquities and Monuments Office (AMO) will be
informed immediately in case of discovery of antiquities or supposed
antiquities in the course of works. |
|
|
Landscape and Visual |
Yau Tam Mei Tsuen or nearby parks
might contain "trees of particular interest (TPI) " which should be
identified and protected in conservation plans. |
•
The finding of broad-brush
tree and vegetation survey, including all TPI(s) that would be directly impacted by the Project, and the
associated mitigation measures, are provided in Section 11 of this EIA Report. •
Sensitivity analysis would be conducted in the detailed design and construction stages to further review and
justify the need for any TPI(s) removal.
|
|
Electric and Magnetic Field |
Due consideration should
be given when planning developments at areas near the existing 400 kV
overhead cables to the south of the Development Area to reduce potential
impact of the electromagnetic field. |
It is expected that the electric and
electromagnetic field generated by the existing 400 kV overhead cables should
be well below the relevant exposure standards and limits, and therefore
adverse impact on the proposed developments of the Project is not anticipated.
|
|
Concern associated with the Proposed River Revitalisation |
A buffer zone should be provided at each side of the revitalised NTMDC to
provide sufficient riparian habitats and to accommodate a wide range of water
flow. |
Open Space and non-building area (a combined
width of 80 m) will be provided along the revitalised NTMDC (total length of
about 2.2 km), serving as a
buffer zone. |
|
Additional water source might be required for the revitalised
NTMDC during dry season. |
Provision for additional water source in dry
season would be reviewed in detailed design stage. |
|
|
Cumulative Environment-al Impact |
Given other major
developments, such as the STT, NOL Main Line and NM Highway ¨C San Tin
Section, interconnected with the Project, all the potential environmental
impacts of the adjacent developments should be addressed so that the
cumulative environmental impacts will not be underestimated. |
With the best available information, the
cumulative impacts arising from the construction and operational phases of
the identified interfacing projects have been addressed in this EIA Report. |
Table 2.3 Comparison of Benefits and Dis-benefits for the
Configuration Options for NTMDC
Options
|
Benefits
|
Dis-benefits
|
Option 1 ¨C Maintain Existing Profile
|
• Preserve existing ecosystem |
•
Undermine the potential of developing an
integrated blue-green infrastructure and connections for people and wildlife
|
Option 2 ¨C Widening of River Channel and Flattening of Southern Bank
|
•
Enhance planting and habitat creation
opportunities
•
Increase the hydraulic capacity of the river
• Enhance
the overall ecological value and support biodiversity
•
Provide opportunities for provision of
water-friendly activity space and pedestrian / cycle routes to enhance
connectivity across the NDA
|
•
Temporary environmental impacts (e.g.
water quality, noise, ecology) caused by construction activities
• More maintenance and management issues (e.g. more frequent desilting works, tree management and vegetation overgrowth,. etc) |
Table 2.4 Comparison of Benefits and Dis-benefits of
Options of Site Formation Works
Options
|
Benefits
|
Dis-benefits
|
Option 1 ¨C Cut Slope
|
•
Slope can be formed in a relatively short
period of time. Surplus of soil/rock resulted from slope trimming can be
reused for backfill and other purposes, such that less excavated materials could be generated.
•
Vegetation growth is more possible
|
•
Less spaces available for development for
smaller site as the slope would occupy a significant footprint
|
Option 2 ¨C Fill Slope
|
•
Slope can be formed in a relatively short
period of time
•
Surplus of soil/rock resulted from slope trimming
can be reused for backfill and other purposes, such that less excavated
materials could be
generated.
•
Vegetation growth is more possible due to
less compacted soil, resulting in increased pore space that enhances moisture
retention and allows for better root penetration.
|
•
Less spaces available for development for
smaller site as the slope would occupy a significant footprint
|
Option 3 ¨C
L-shaped Retaining Wall
|
•
Vertical wall face can be formed to maximise
development area
•
Soils excavated from temporary cutting could
be reused for backfilling behind the wall face, such that the generation of excavated materials could be minimised.
•
Economical design can be achieved as the
self-weight of backfill is used to stabilise the wall
|
•
Vegetation growth is difficult and incurs
high maintenance cost
|
Option 4 ¨C Cantilevered Pile Retaining Wall
|
•
Ability to retain greater height
•
Maximised development area on both sides of
the retaining wall
|
•
Relatively costly for constructing
cantilevered pile wall, in particular large diameter bored piles
•
Heavy plants and equipment for construction
•
Vegetation growth is difficult and incurs
high maintenance cost
|
Option 5 ¨C Tie-back Wall
|
•
Ability to retain greater height
economically
|
•
Tie-backs may be restricted by the
development at wall top
•
Vegetation growth is difficult and incurs
high maintenance cost
|
Table 2.5 Summary of Key Environmental Issues Avoided / Minimised and Sensitive Areas Protected
|
Environmental Issues Avoided/Minimised and Sensitive Areas
Protected |
|
|
Avoidance
of Impact on Sites of Conservation Importance |
• Encroachment of LTCP, CA, Wetland Conservation Area, Priority Site for Enhanced
Conservation and Other Specified Uses (Wetland Conservation Park) have been avoided. |
|
Avoidance/Minimisation
of Ecological Impact on Pond Habitat |
•
Impact to the ponds which are considered to have
moderate ecological value, to the west of San Tin Highway have been avoided. |
|
Incorporation of Wildlife Corridor
and Animal Barriers Design |
•
Incorporation of wildlife corridor
and animal barriers design
will be
adopted during the detailed design of the proposed road connection to/from
STT to mitigate habitat fragmentation and maintain the movement access for
non-flying mammals including species of conservation importance. |
|
Preservation of Natural
Habitats |
•
Sites GB.1 and GB.2 have
been retained in the RODP such that the loss of natural habitats
and the associated flora species of conservation importance could be avoided.
|
|
Revitalisation of
NTMDC |
• NTMDC will
be revitalised to serve as green buffer, enhancing biodiversity as well as the overall ecological value. |
|
Avoidance
of Impact from the Existing Odour Sources (i.e. chicken farms, LBF and TMB
sewage treatment plant) |
•
The planned air sensitive receivers (ASRs) have been proposed to be situated away from existing odour
sources. •
Height restriction of air sensitive uses and
fresh air intake at concerned sites that fall within odour exceedance zone of
existing odour sources has been proposed. |
|
Clearing of Existing Odour
Sources |
•
A chicken farm within the Project
Site will be removed to minimise the odour impact to the planned ASRs under
the Project. |
|
Provision of Sustainable
Transport Infrastructure to Promote Low-carbon Living |
•
Pedestrian-friendly
environment and robust cycling network has been proposed in the RODP to
promote walkability and cycling for low-carbon living. |
|
Proper Design of TIH and PTT |
•
Operational fixed noise
impacts from the proposed TIH and PTT to noise sensitive receivers (NSRs) are
avoided. |
|
Provision of Direct Road
Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures |
•
NSRs will be protected to
achieve the statutory road traffic noise requirement through adoption of
direct noise mitigation measures such as provision of low noise road
surfacing, absorptive type noise barriers, and acoustic windows/balconies or
acoustic windows/balconies lined with sound absorptive material. |
|
Preservation of Points of
Local Historical Interests |
•
Local resources such as
WCAH and the former Yau Tam Mei Primary School will be preserved in situ
within the Project Site in
the RODP. • Flexibility for potential adaptive reuse
of building structures by future project proponents of UniTown
is also allowed in the RODP for former Yau Tam Mei Primary School. |
|
Implementation of an Environmental
Monitoring and Audit Programme during Construction and Operational Phases |
•
To ensure that all the
recommended measures are in place. |
Table 2.6 Preliminary
Construction and Population Intake Schedule
|
Develop-ment Stage |
Area |
Rationale of Phasing |
Earliest Date for
Commencement of Infrastructure Works |
Earliest Date for
Availability of Land for Building Works |
Anticipated First Occupation/
Population Intake Date |
|
Phase
1 |
• DRE site (RSc.1) • Integrated Hospital
(G.8) & adjacent ESS site (G.9) • Part of UniTown (G.11) • Sewage pumping station
(G.1) • Road network connecting
to the Integrated Hospital |
• Early handover of the
sites for building works (by others) |
Q1
2027 |
Q4
2028 |
2033
for DRE site |
|
Phase 2 |
• Remaining UniTown (G.6, G.10, G.11, G.12) • Residential Site (R.3,
R.4) • Remaining G/ICs, School
(E.1 & E.2), Open Space (O.2, O.5-O.7), Amenity Areas • Majority of road network • NTMDC |
• To commence
infrastructure works for targeted population intake • To allow early handover
of UniTown |
Q3
2028 |
Q2 2031 |
Q2
2034 |
|
Phase
3 |
• Residential Site R.1,
R.2 • Remaining open space • Remaining roadworks,
landscape works, riverside & site formation works |
• To suit the programme of interfacing projects |
Q3
2030 |
Q3
2032 |
Q2 2036 |
¡¤
Site formation
and development for key
infrastructures including retention tank, RCPs and
utilities laying, etc.;
¡¤
Site formation
and development for remaining areas of UniTown to
facilitate completion for handover;
¡¤
Site formation for R.3 and R.4;
¡¤
Site formation
and development for ¡°E¡± and ¡°G¡± sites such as primary school, etc.;
¡¤
Road improvement
to Chuk Yau Road, Ngau Tam Mei Road and San Tam Road;
¡¤
Construction of District
Distributor Road D1, proposed road connection to/from STT, Road L1, Road L2, Road L3, associated
junction works and slip roads connecting San Tin Highway and local roads, pedestrian
and cycling connectivity including cycle bridge, associated pedestrian walkway
and cycle tracks;
¡¤
Site clearance
and revitalisation of NTMDC; and
¡¤
Construction of
associated open space and amenity areas.
¡¤
Site formation
for R.1 and R.2 after partial demolition of the transitional housing;
¡¤
Development of
open space after partial demolition of the transitional housing; and
¡¤
Remaining
roadworks, landscape works, riverside and site formation works.
Table 2.7 Summary
of Potential Cumulative Impacts from Major Concurrent Projects
|
Major Concurrent
Project |
Project Proponent |
Tentative
Construction Programme |
Brief Description of the
Concurrent Project |
Potential
Cumulative Impact |
||
|
Start |
Complete |
Construction |
Operation |
|||
|
NOL Main Line |
MTRCL |
2025 |
2034 |
The
proposed NOL Main Line includes an underground railway corridor of about 10.7
kilometres between the Kam Sheung Road Station and Kwu
Tung Station, with three intermediate stations at San Tin, NTM and Au Tau, NTM Depot and ancillary buildings. |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤ Ecology ¡¤
Fisheries ¡¤
Landscape
|
¡¤ Noise ¡¤
Landscape
and Visual |
|
Northern Metropolis Highway ¨C San Tin Section |
Highways Department |
Under Study |
¡¤
On or Before 2036 |
The alignment of San Tin Section links the interchange
at San Tin Highway and traverses the developed area in Mo Fan Heung, mainly
consisting of an approximately 8.5 km long dual three-lane carriageway and
five interchanges. |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤ Ecology ¡¤
Fisheries ¡¤ Landscape |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤ Landscape and Visual |
|
Ngau Tam Mei Water Treatment
Works Extension |
Water Supplies Department |
Q1 2025 |
Q4 2030 |
The project will include the extension
of NTMWTW within the site compound with the aim of upgrading the water
treatment capability and enhancing the treatment efficiency. It also includes
the construction of extension of NTM Fresh Water Primary Service Reservoir
(FWPSR) adjacent to the existing FWPSR and a tunnel in
connection with the NTMWTW, laying of fresh water
trunk mains from the extended NTMWTW to near Tan Kwai Tsuen. |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤ Ecology ¡¤ Fisheries |
¡¤ Noise |
|
Retrofitting of Noise Barriers on San Tin
Highway |
Highways Department |
Under Planning |
Under Planning |
The purpose of the project is to
mitigate the traffic noise on Mai Po San Tsuen, Casa Paradizo,
Green Crest, Hang Fook Garden, Ha San Wai, Merry Garden, San Wai Tsuen and
Pok Wai near San Tin Highway by retrofitting of noise barriers. |
As the construction
programme is unavailable at the time of preparation of this EIA, the
potential cumulative impact is not assessed. |
As the construction
programme is unavailable at the time of preparation of this EIA, the
retrofitted noise barriers on San Tin Highway are not included in the road
traffic noise assessment. |
|
Site Formation and
Infrastructure Works for Public Housing Development at Sha Po, Yuen Long |
CEDD |
2025 |
2031 |
The project scope comprises site formation
works, geotechnical works, roadworks, sewerage and drainage works; associated tree felling, transplanting and
preservation works; and ancillary works including waterworks, landscaping
works, environmental mitigation measures, etc. for public housing development
at Sha Po |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise |
¡¤ Landscape
and Visual |
|
First Phase Development of the
New Territories North ¨C San Tin / Lok Ma Chau Development Node ¨C
Investigation |
CEDD & PlanD |
End 2024 |
2039 |
The project covers a development area of 610 ha which
is located at the
heart of the NM and in proximity to
Shenzhen's I&T Zone. San Tin Technopole will
bolster I&T, residential spaces, community and commercial facilities, and
other vital infrastructures in Hong Kong. |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤ Ecology ¡¤ Fisheries ¡¤ Landscape |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤ Landscape and Visual |
|
Proposed Residential
Development at Various Lots in D.D. 104 and the Adjoining Government
Land in Yuen Long, N.T. (Approved
Planning Application No. Y/YL-MP/10) |
Capital Chance Limited |
Under
Planning |
Under
Planning |
The project is a low- to medium-rise residential development project
with local commercial uses, transportation and GIC facilities to serve the
future residents and the neighbours, and a landscaped public open space. |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤ Landscape |
¡¤ Landscape
and Visual |
|
Proposed Low-rise and
Low-density Residential Development at Various Lots and their Adjoining
Government Land in D.D. 104, East of Kam Pok Road, Mai Po,
Yuen Long, N.T. (Approved
Planning Application No. A/YL-MP/287) |
Glory Queen Limited |
Under
Planning |
Under
Planning |
The project is a low-rise and low-density residential development
project. Its scope covers the filling of ponds/land and excavation works for
the proposed residential development. |
¡¤ Air Quality ¡¤ Noise ¡¤
Landscape |
¡¤
Landscape and Visual |
[1] River Revitalisation
for the Good of Water (https://www.dsd.gov.hk/EN/Publicity_and_Publications/Publicity/
DSD_Sustainability_Reports/1/river_revitalisation.html)