Construction of Facility Foundations for the Black Point Location

E1           Construction of Facility Foundations

E1.1             General

The terminal structures such as pipe racks, terminal facilities and buildings are considered to be piled foundation in view of the loadings and constructability mainly over the reclamation area where they are overlying thick marine sediments.  The LNG tanks are located within the cut slope areas for which ground bearing raft foundations are anticipated depending on the suitability of the rock beneath the formation level.

The jetty extends from the proposed seawalls to the approach channel for berthing of LNG carriers. The berthing head, trestle, mooring and breasting dolphins will be constructed on a series of pile caps supported on marine bored and/or driven piles founded on rock.  The potential access for LNG carriers will be via the waterway entering the approach channel and turning basin before berthing.  Piling for the jetty will be constrained by the construction limitations due to significant marine traffic in fairways and restricted areas.  These factors are important in the site assessment and comparison process. Mitigation measures will be considered to reduce the length of jetty and the noise and vibrations associated with the pile installation works. 

The receiving terminal requires the use of marine access for normal terminal operation, construction plant, materials and labour during construction.  Sites with alternative land access will have programme advantages in both construction and operation stages.

E1.2             Assessment Parameters

In order to assess the engineering implications of the marine and on-land installation works at each of the sites the following assessment parameters have been considered:-

·          Terminal facility structures piling works;

·          Jetty piling works; and,

·          Water front access.

 

E2           Terminal Facility Structure

E2.1             Option 1 – Base Case

The pipe racks and terminal infrastructures are located on areas of reclamation and these structures will be piled.  Two of the LNG tanks will be located behind the cut slope and will be supported on a raft foundation on rock.

E2.2             Option 2 – Full Reclamation

All the LNG tanks, the pipe racks and terminal infrastructures are located on areas of reclamation and these structures will be piled.

E2.3             Option 3 – Full Excavation

All the LNG tanks, the pipe racks and terminal infrastructures are located behind the cut slope and these structures will be founded directly on rock using pad or raft footings.


E3           Jetty Piling Works

E3.1             Option 1 – Base Case

The estimated length of the jetty from the proposed seawall is approximately 100m long for berthing of LNG carriers. 

E3.2             Option 2 – Full Reclamation

The estimated length of the jetty is approximately 100m long for berthing of LNG carriers.

E3.3             Option 3 – Full Excavation

The estimated length of the jetty is approximately 180m long.

 

E4           Water Front Access

The Black Point site has both waterfront and land access will be available for site formation and piling works.

 

E5           Summary for Facility Foundation Construction

A summary of the parameter values and relative scores derived from the engineering assessment for the facility foundation construction is given in Table F1 below.

Table E1 - Summary for Facility Foundation Construction

Parameter

Option 1
(Base Case)

Option 2
(Full Reclamation)

Option 3
(Full Excavation)

Terminal facility structures piling works

RS = 3

RS = 1

RS = 4

Jetty piling works
length (m)

RS = 3

(100)

RS = 3

(100)

RS = 1

(180)

Water front access

RS = 3

RS = 3

RS = 3

RS = Relative Score


E6           Scoring for Facility Foundation Construction

Each of the parameters summarised above in Table E1 have been scored in accordance with the procedure described in Section 2.1.  The results are shown below in Table E2 for each layout option.  The table also shows the total score for each layout option derived using the weightings given in Table 2.7.

Table E2 – Scoring for Each Layout Option at Black Point for Facility Foundation Construction

Parameter

Weight

Option 1
(Base Case)

Option 2
(Full Reclamation)

Option 3
(Full Excavation)

Score

WS

Score

WS

Score

WS

Terminal facility structures piling works

0.3

3

0.90

1

0.30

4

1.20

Jetty piling works

0.5

3

1.50

3

1.50

1

0.50

Water front access

0.2

3

0.60

3

0.60

3

0.60

Total Weighted Score

 

3.00

 

2.40

 

2.30

Normalised Score

5.00

4.00

3.83

 

From the result of the assessment of all parameters for the construction of the facility foundations, Option 1 is the preferred layout followed by the Option 2 and 3 layouts.