Agreement No. CE
61/2007 (CE)
North East New
Territories New Development Areas Planning and Engineering Study -
Investigation
Final Environmental
Impact Assessment Report
CONTENT
1.1 Project Background
1.2 The Assignment
1.3 The Study Area
1.4 EIA Study Brief
1.5 Designated Projects
1.6 Objectives of the EIA Report
1.7 Structure of the Report
2.1 General Description of the Project
2.2 Need for the Project
2.3 Revised Recommended Outline Development Plan
2.4 Key Infrastructure
2.5 Nature, Benefits and Scope of the Project
2.6 Construction Method
2.7 Implementation Programme
2.8 Concurrent Project
3.1 Overview
3.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
3.3 Description of Environment
3.4 Air Sensitive Receivers
3.5 Assessment Methodology
3.6 Identification of Environmental Impact
3.7 Prediction and Evaluation of Impacts
3.8 Mitigation Measures
3.9 Conclusion
4.1 Overview
4.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
4.3 Description of the Environment
4.4 Potential Concurrent Project
4.5 Noise Sensitive Receivers
4.6 Assessment Methodology
4.7 Identification of Impacts
4.8 Evaluation of Impacts
4.9 Mitigation Measures
4.10 Assessment of Side Effects and Constraints
4.11 Evaluation of Constraints on Planned Noise Sensitive Developments/ Landuses
4.12 Summary of Environmental Mitigation Measures
4.13 Residual Environmental Impacts
4.14 Conclusion
5.1 Overview
5.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
5.3 Description of the Environment
5.4 Water Quality Sensitive Receivers
5.5 Assessment Methodology
5.6 Identification and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts
5.7 Mitigation Measures
5.8 Cumulative Impacts
5.9 Residual Environmental Impacts
5.10 Summary
5.11 Reference
6.1 Introduction
6.2 Methodology and Design Criteria
6.3 Existing and Planned Sewerage Infrastructure
6.4 Review of Findings under Previous NENT Study
6.5 Estimation of Sewage Flows
6.6 Effluent Quality and Discharge Standards of SWH STW
6.7 Sewage Treatment in Shek Wu Hui Sewage Treatment Works
6.8 Kwu Tung North NDA
6.9 Fanling North NDA
6.10 Treated Sewage Effluent (TSE) Reuse for NDAs
6.11 Interface with Other Projects
6.12 Conclusion and Recommendation
6.13 Reference
7 Waste Management Implications
7.1 Overview
7.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
7.3 Description of the Environment
7.4 Assessment Methodology
7.5 Identification and Evaluation of Waste Management Implications
7.6 Mitigation Measures
7.7 Residual Waste Management Implications
7.8 Conclusion
8.1 Overview
8.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
8.3 Assessment Methodology
8.4 Description of the Environment
8.5 Site Investigation
8.6 Identification and Evaluation of Land Contamination
8.7 Way Forward for Dealing High Background Arsenic in KTN
8.8 Health Risk Assessment for Arsenic-Containing Soil
8.9 Conclusion
9.1 Introduction
9.2 Scope and Objectives
9.3 Study Approach
9.4 Cases to Be Assessed
9.5 Description of Sheung Shui Water Treatment Works
9.6 Meteorological Conditions
9.7 Population Considered in the Assessment
9.8 Hazard Identification
9.9 Consequence Analysis
9.10 Rationalization of Chlorine Release Scenarios and Estimation of Scenario Frequencies
9.11 Quantitative Risk Assessment
9.12 Conclusions and Recommendations
9.13 References
10.1 Overview
10.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
10.3 Description of the Environment
10.4 Assessment Methodology
10.5 Qualitative Risk Assessment
10.6 Protective and Precautionary Measures
10.7 Conclusion
11.1 Overview
11.2 Environmental Legislation, Standard and Guidelines
11.3 Assessment Methodology
11.4 Description of Environment
11.5 Identification and Evaluation of Impact
11.6 Mitigation Measures
11.7 Conclusions
11.8 References
12 Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment
12.1 Introduction
12.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
12.3 Scope of the Study
12.4 Landscape Impact Assessment Methodology
12.5 Review of Planning and Development Control Framework
12.6 Landscape Baseline Conditions
12.7 Sources of Impacts
12.8 Landscape Impact Assessment
12.9 Landscape & Visual Mitigation Measures
12.1 Visual Impact Assessment Methodology
12.11 Visual Baseline Conditions
12.12 Visual Impact Assessment
12.13 Conclusion – Schedule 3 DP
12.14 LVIA for Schedule 2 Designated Projects – General Introduction
12.15 Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines
12.16 Scope of the Study
12.17 Schedule 2 Concurrent Projects
12.18 Landscape Impact Assessment Methodology
12.19 Visual Impact Assessment Methodology
12A DP Package A
12A.1 KTN Schedule 2 DP 1, 2, 3 and 4 (Package A)
12A.2 Review of Planning and Development Control Framework
12A.3 Landscape Baseline Conditions
12A.4 Details of Site Formation Impacts – KTN Schedule 2 DPs 1, 2, 3 and 4
12A.5 Sources of Impacts
12A.6 Landscape Impact Assessment
12A.7 Summary of key landscape impacts
12A.8 Significance of landscape impacts before Mitigation
12A.9 Landscape and Visual Mitigation Measures for Construction and Operation
12A.10 Significance of Residual Landscape Impacts Upon Mitigation
12A.11 Visual Impact Assessment
12A.12 Sensitivity of VSRs/VPs
12A.13 Magnitude of Visual Change
12A.14 Significance of Visual Impacts
12A.15 Conclusion
12B DP Package B
12B.1 KTN Schedule 2 DP 5 (Package B)
12B.2 Review of Planning and Development Control Framework
12B.3 Landscape Baseline Conditions
12B.4 Details of Site Formation Impacts – KTN Schedule 2 DP5
12B.5 Potential Landscape and Visual Impacts
12B.6 Landscape Impact Assessment
12B.7 Summary of key landscape impacts
12B.8 Significance of Landscape Impacts before mitigation
12B.9 Landscape and Visual Mitigation Measures for Construction and Operation
12B.10 Significance of Residual Landscape Impactsupon mitigation
12B.11 Visual Impact Assessment
12B.12 Magnitude of Visual Change
12B.13 Significance of Visual Impacts
12B.14 Conclusion
12C DP Package C
12C.1 Introduction
12C.2 Review of Planning and Development Control Framework
12C.3 Landscape Baseline Conditions
12C.4 Details of Site Formation Impacts – Schedule 2 DPs 7, 11 and 13
12C.5 Potential Landscape and Visual Impacts
12C.6 Landscape Impact Assessment
12C.7 Summary of key landscape impacts
12C.8 Significance of Landscape Impacts
12C.9 Landscape and Visual Mitigation Measures for Construction and Operation
12C.10 Significance of Residual Landscape Impacts upon mitigation
12C.11 Visual Impact Assessment
12C.12 Visual Baseline Conditions
12C.13 Visual Impact Assessment
12C.14 Significance of Visual Impacts
12C.15 Conclusion
12D DP Package D
12D.1 Introduction
12D.2 Review of Planning and Development Control Framework
12D.3 Landscape Baseline Conditions
12D.4 Details of Site Formation Impacts – FLN Schedule 2 DPs 8, 9, 10and 12
12D.5 Sources of Impacts
12D.6 Landscape Impact Assessment
12D.7 Summary of Key Landscape Impacts
12D.8 Significance of Landscape Impacts
12D.9 Landscape and Visual Mitigation Measures
12D.10 Significance of Residual Landscape Impacts upon mitigation
12D.11 Visual Impact Assessment
12D.12 Sensitivity of VSRs/VPs
12D.13 Visual Impact Assessment
12D.14 Significance of Visual Impacts
12D.15 Conclusion
13 Ecological Impact Assessment
13.1 Introduction
13.2 Ecological Resources and Development Context of the NDAs and Surrounding Areas
13.3 Review of Existing Literature Related to Ecological Conditions in the Study Area
13.4 Survey Methodology
13.5 Ecological Profile of the Study Area
13.6 Description and Ecological Evaluation of Habitats and Species
13.7 Prediction and Evaluation of Ecological Impacts of the Proposed Development
13.8 Mitigation of Impacts
13.9 Implementation, management and maintenance of mitigation measures
13.10 Residual Impacts
13.11 Ecological Monitoring & Audit
13.12 Conclusion
13.13 References
14 Fisheries Impact Assessment
14.1 Introduction
14.2 Environmental Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Guidelines
14.3 Methodology
14.4 Baseline Conditions – Review of Existing Information
14.5 Baseline Conditions – Site Investigation
14.6 Identification and Evaluation of Impacts
14.7 Mitigation Measures
14.8 Residual Environmental Impacts and Monitoring and Audit
14.9 Conclusions
15 Environmental Monitoring and Audit Requirements
15.1 Overview
15.2 Project Organization
15.3 EM&A Manual
15.4 Project Implementation Schedule
15.5 EM&A Programme
16 Summary of Environment Outcomes
16.1 Overview
16.2 Population and Environmental Areas Protected
16.3 Environmental Friendly Design and Benefit
16.4 Summary of the Measures taken for the Avoidance and Minimization of Environmental Impacts
17.1 Air Quality
17.2 Noise
17.3 Water Quality
17.4 Sewerage and Sewage Implication
17.5 Waste
17.6 Land Contamination
17.7 Hazard to Life
17.8 Landfill Gas
17.9 Cultural Heritage
17.10 Landscape and Visual
17.11 Ecology
17.12 Fisheries
17.13 Environmental Monitoring and Audit Requirements
LIST OF APPENDICES
2 Project Description
Appendix 2.1 RODPs Development Parameters
Appendix 2.2 Construction Programme
3 Air Quality Assessment
Appendix 3.1 Preliminary Construction Program
Appendix 3.2 Justification for the Percentage of Active Works Areas and Dust Suppression Efficiency
Appendix 3.3 Details of Dust Emission Sources and Calculations
Appendix 3.4 Key Assumptions for EmFAC
Appendix 3.5 Hourly Vehicular Emission Rates
Appendix 3.6 In-tunnel Air Quality Assessment
Appendix 3.7 Calculations of Industrial Emission Factors
Appendix 3.8 Details and Calculations of Odour Emission Sources
Appendix 3.9 Result of Unmitigated Cumulative TSP Concentration
Appendix 3.10 Result of Cumulative NO2 and RSP Concentration
Appendix 3.11 Result of Cumulative SO2 Concentration
Appendix 3.12 Result of Cumulative Odour Concentration
Appendix 3.13 Result of Mitigated TSP Concentration for Tier-1 Assessment
Appendix 3.14 Result of Mitigated TSP Concentration for Tier-2 Assessment
Appendix 3.15 Result of Mitigated TSP Concentration for Tier-3 Assessment
4 Noise Impact
Appendix 4.1a Locations of Assessment Points – Construction Noise
Appendix 4.1b Locations of Assessment Points – Road Traffic Noise
Appendix 4.1c Locations of Assessment Points – Fixed Noise
Appendix 4.1d Locations of Assessment Points – Helicopter Noise
Appendix 4.1e Photos of Existing NSRs
Appendix 4.1f Site Formation Level and Road mpd Level
Appendix 4.1g Building Name, Landuse, Floor of Each and Selected Assessment Point
Appendix 4.2 Construction Programme
Appendix 4.3 Background Noise Measurement Locations for Fixed Noise Assessment
Appendix 4.5 Government Flying Service Memo Ref:AIR/10/14(3) dated 29 September 2008
Appendix 4.6 Secretary of Security (Memo Ref. ( ) in SBCR 12/1488/95 Pt.3 dated March 3, 2009
Appendix 4.7 Government Flying Service Memo Ref: AIR/10/14(4) dated 17 March 2011
Appendix 4.8 Hong Kong Police Force Memo Ref.74 in CP Con 15/47 Pt 2 dated 4 July 2011
Appendix 4.9a Plant Inventory Adopted for Each Workfront (KTN)
Appendix 4.9b Plant Inventory Adopted for Each Workfront (FLN)
Appendix 4.10a Notional Distance between Assessment Points and Workfronts (KTN)
Appendix 4.10b Notional Distance between Assessment Points and Workfronts (FLN)
Appendix 4.11a Unmitigated Construction Noise Impacts (KTN)
Appendix 4.11b Unmitigated Construction Noise Impacts (FLN)
Appendix 4.12a Monthly Unmitigated Construction Noise Impacts from Each Workfront (KTN)
Appendix 4.12b Monthly Unmitigated Construction Noise Impacts from Each Workfront (FLN)
Appendix 4.13a Computer Plot of Road Scheme (KTN)
Appendix 4.13b Computer Plot of Road Scheme (FLN)
Appendix 4.14a Road Hierarchy (KTN)
Appendix 4.14b Road Hierarchy (FLN)
Appendix 4.15a Details of Road Traffic Data (KTN)
Appendix 4.15b Details of Road Traffic Data (FLN)
Appendix 4.15c Approval from TD on Traffic Data
Appendix 4.16a Low Noise Road Surface Locations (KTN)
Appendix 4.16b Low Noise Road Surface Locations (FLN)
Appendix 4.17 Highway Department Ref: (N54Z) in HNT/703/N/154 dated 13 April 2012
Appendix 4.18 Retrofitting Barrier along Fanling Highway
Appendix 4.19 Environmental Permit (EP-404/2011)
Appendix 4.19a Sample Calculation for Road Traffic Noise Assessment
Appendix 4.20a Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (KTN) at Year 2044
Appendix 4.20b Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (FLN) at Year 2044
Appendix 4.21a Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (KTN) at Year 2036
Appendix 4.21b Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (KTN) at Year 2043
Appendix 4.21c Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (FLN) at Year 2038
Appendix 4.22 Determination of SWL of single mode shooting of each weapon
Appendix 4.23 Correspondence with HKPF
Appendix 4.24 Detailed Calculation of Shooting Noise Impacts on NSRs
Appendix 4.24a Predicted SPL at NSRs due to Lo Wu Classification Range
Appendix 4.25 Detailed Calculation of Ventilation Shafts Noise Impacts on NSRs
Appendix 4.25a Predicted SPL at NSRs due to Ventilation Shaft
Appendix 4.26 Detailed Calculation of Maximum Allowable SWL of DCS
Appendix 4.26a Predicted SPL at NSRs due to DCS
Appendix 4.27 Detailed Calculation of Maximum Allowable SWL of STW
Appendix 4.27a Predicted SPL at NSRs due to STW
Appendix 4.28 Detailed Calculation of Crowd and PA Noise Impacts on NSRs
Appendix 4.28a Predicted SPL at NSRs due to Crowd and PA Noise
Appendix 4.29 Detailed Calculation of Maximum Allowable SWL of SPS / PS
Appendix 4.29a Predicted SPL at NSRs due to SPS / PS
Appendix 4.30 Detailed Calculation of Helicopter Noise Impacts on NSRs
Appendix 4.31 Drawings Showing Barrier, Enclosure and Acoustic Mat for Construction Noise
Appendix 4.32a Mitigated Construction Noise Impacts on NSRs (KTN)
Appendix 4.32b Mitigated Construction Noise Impacts on NSRs (FLN)
Appendix 4.33a Monthly Mitigated Construction Noise Impacts from Each Workfront (KTN)
Appendix 4.33b Monthly Mitigated Construction Noise Impacts from Each Workfront (FLN)
Appendix 4.34 Record of Minutes held on 28 March 2011
Appendix 4.35 Typical Section of Semi-enclosure and Enclosure Design
Appendix 4.36a Details of Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (Mitigated Scenario - KTN) at Year 2044
Appendix 4.36b Details of Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (Mitigated Scenario - FLN) at Year 2044
Appendix 4.37a Details of Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (Mitigated Scenario - KTN) at Year 2036
Appendix 4.37b Details of Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (Mitigated Scenario - KTN) at Year 2043
Appendix 4.37c Details of Road Traffic Noise Impacts on NSRs (Mitigated Scenario - FLN) at Year 2038
Appendix 4.38a Not Used
Appendix 4.39a Details breakdown of protected and benefitted land uses (KTN)
Appendix 4.39b Details breakdown of protected and benefitted land uses (FLN)
5 Water Quality Impact
Appendix 5.1 Descriptions of Water Streams
Appendix 5.2 Loading from Non-point Sources
6 Sewerage
Impact Assessment
Appendix 6.1 Development Parameters
Appendix 6.2 Supplementary Development Parameters
Appendix 6.3 Estimation of Sewage Flows from NDAs
Appendix 6.4 Estimation of Sewage Flows to SWHSTW
Appendix 6.5 Sewerage System Design Calculations
Appendix 6.6 InfoWorks Hydraulic Modelling Results
Appendix 6.7 Proposed Effluent Discharge Standards of SWHSTW
8 Land Contamination Impacts
Appendix 8.1 Contamination Assessment Plan (CAP)
Appendix 8.2 Contamination Assessment Plan (CAP) for Government Sites
Appendix 8.3 Contamination Assessment Report (CAR) for Government Sites
9 Hazard to Life
Appendix 9.1 Population Distribution and Population Assumptions
Appendix 9.2 Site Survey on Riverside/Seafront Promenade Areas at Sha Tin
Appendix 9.3 Historical Incidents from MHIDAS Database
11 Cultural Heritage
Appendix 11.1 Declared Monuments and Graded Historic Buildings Records Identified in the CHAA
Appendix 11.2a Detailed Plans showing Identified Built Heritage Items within the KTN NDA and Associated Infrastructure Works CHAA
Appendix 11.6a Detailed Plans showing Identified Locations with Archaeological Interest within the KTN NDA and Associated Infrastructure Works CHAA
13 Ecological Impact Assessment
Appendix 13.10 Long Valley Nature Park: Preliminary Management Plan
14 Fisheries Impact Assessment
Appendix 14.1 Photo records of site visit
15 Environmental Monitoring and Audit Requirements
Appendix 15-1 Project Implementation Schedule
16 Summary of Environment Outcomes
Appendix 16.1 Key Assessment Assumptions and Limitation of Assessment Methodologies
Appendix 16.2 Environmental Assessment for minor change in revised RODP
LIST OF FIGURES
1 Introduction
Figure 1.1 KTN NDA and FLN NDA- EIA Study Area
Figure 1.2 Locations of Designated Projects in KTN NDA
Figure 1.3 Locations of Designated Projects in FLN NDA
Figure 1.4 Locations of Designated Projects in Fanling Bypass
2 Project Description
Figure 2.1 Revised RODP of KTN NDA
Figure 2.2 Revised RODP of FLN NDA
Figure 2.3 Road Network in Study Area
Figure 2.4 Proposed Road and Improvement Works
Figure 2.5 Proposed Road and Improvement Works
Figure 2.6 Proposed Road and Improvement Works
Figure 2.7 Proposed Road and Improvement Works
Figure 2.8 Sections for Po Shek Wu Interchange Improvement
Figure 2.9 Sections for Po Shek Wu Interchange Improvement
Figure 2.10 Layout of Sewage Pumping Station for NDAs Development
Figure 2.11 Layout Plan of the Proposed Sewage Treatment Works Extension in FLN NDA
Figure 2.11a Proposed Treated Sewage Effluent (TSE) Mains in Kwu Tung North NDA
Figure 2.11b Proposed Treated Sewage Effluent (TSE) Mains in Fanling North NDA
Figure 2.11c Proposed Treated Sewage Effluent (TSE) Mains within the Study Area
Figure 2.12 Proposed Road and Improvement Works
Figure 2.13 Proposed Road and Improvement Works
Figure 2.14 Proposed Road and Improvement Works
Figure 2.15 Sections for Fanling Bypass
Figure 2.16 Sections for Fanling Bypass
Figure 2.17 Sections for Fanling Bypass
Figure 2.18 Reprovisioning of North District Temporary Wholesale Market (On Completion)
Figure 2.19 Conceptual Cross Section of Steel Canopy at North District Temporary Wholesale Market
Figure 2.20 General Layout for Development Packages
Figure 2.20a Proposed Network and Hierarchy in KTN NDA
Figure 2.20b Proposed Network and Hierarchy in FLN NDA
Figure 2.21 Locations of Concurrent Projects – Construction Phase
Figure 2.22 Locations of Concurrent Projects – Operational Phase
3 Air Quality Assessment
Figure 3.1 Location of Existing Air Sensitive Receivers of KTN NDA
Figure 3.2 Location of Existing Air Sensitive Receivers of FLN NDA
Figure 3.3 Location of Planned Air Sensitive Receivers of KTN NDA
Figure 3.4 Location of Planned Air Sensitive Receivers of FLN NDA
Figure 3.5 Road Networks Implementation Schedule for KTN NDA
Figure 3.6 Road Networks Implementation Schedule for FLN NDA
Figure 3.7 Location of Chimneys Adjacent to KTN and FLN NDAs
Figure 3.8 Locations of Proposed/Existing Air Pollution Sources in KTN NDA
Figure 3.9 Locations of Proposed/Existing Air Pollution Sources in FLN NDA
Figure 3.11 Contours of Cumulative Unmitigated Max. 1-Hour TSP Concentration at 1.5m above Ground in KTN NDA in Year 2018
Figure 3.29 Contours of Cumulative Max. 1-Hour NO2 Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of KTN NDA in Year 2021
Figure 3.32 Contours of Cumulative Max. 1-Hour NO2 Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of FLN NDA in Year 2022
Figure 3.35 Contours of Cumulative Max. 24-Hour RSP Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of KTN NDA in Year 2021
Figure 3.37 Contours of Cumulative Max. 24-Hour RSP Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of FLN NDA in Year 2022
Figure 3.39 Contours of Cumulative Max. 1-Hour NO2 Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of KTN NDA in Year 2029
Figure 3.42 Contours of Cumulative Max. 1-Hour NO2 Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of FLN NDA in Year 2029
Figure 3.45 Contours of Cumulative Max. 24-Hour RSP Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of KTN NDA in Year 2029
Figure 3.47 Contours of Cumulative Max. 24-Hour RSP Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of FLN NDA in Year 2029
Figure 3.49 Contours of Cumulative Max. 1-Hour SO2 Concentration (Chimney Impact) at 10m above Ground of KTN NDA
Figure 3.52 Contours of Cumulative Max. 1-Hour SO2 Concentration (Chimney Impact) at 40m above Ground of FLN NDA
Figure 3.55a Contours of Cumulative Odour Concentration at 1.5m above Ground of FLN NDA
Figure 3.55b Contours of Cumulative Odour Concentration at 55m above Ground of FLN NDA
Figure 3.56 Contours of Cumulative Mitigated Max. 1-Hour TSP Concentration at 1.5m above Ground in KTN NDA in Year 2018 (Tier 1)
Figure 3.58 Contours of Cumulative Mitigated Max. 1-Hour TSP Concentration at 1.5m above Ground in KTN NDA in Year 2018 (Tier 2)
4 Noise Impact
Figure 4.1 Locations of Fixed and Helicopter Noise Sources within 300m from the Study Area (KTN)
Figure 4.2 Locations of Fixed and Helicopter Noise Sources within 300m from the Study Area (FLN)
Figure 4.3 Locations of NSRs outside KTN
Figure 4.4 Locations of NSRs outside FLN
Figure 4.5 Locations of NSRs near FLB
Figure 4.6 Locations of Future NSRs in KTN
Figure 4.7 Locations of Future NSRs in FLN
Figure 4.8 Ranges of Helicopter Approach and Departure Path
Figure 4.9a Locations and Extent of Mitigation Measures at Year 2044 (KTN)
Figure 4.9b Locations and Extent of Mitigation Measures at Year 2044 (FLN)
Figure 4.10a Not Used
Figure 4.10b Locations and Extent of Further Mitigation Measures at Year 2044 (FLN)
Figure 4.11a Locations of Proposed Social Welfares Facilities with Residential Premises and Home for the Elderly (KTN)
Figure 4.12a Locations of Proposed Kindergarten (KTN)
Figure 4.12b Locations of Proposed Kindergarten (FLN)
5 Water Quality Impact
Figure 5.1 Drainage Basins and Water Gathering Ground
Figure 5.2 Existing and Planned Drainage Systems in Ng Tung and San Tin Basin
Figure 5.3 EPD’s Water Monitoring Stations within River Indus and River Beas
Figure 5.6 Typical Layout of Cofferdam
Figure 5.7 Location of Temporary Cofferdam in KTN NDA
Figure 5.8 Location of Temporary Cofferdam in FLN NDA
6 Sewerage
Impact Assessment
Figure
6.1 Existing, Planned and
Proposed Sewerage System within Study Area
Figure
6.2 Existing Layout of SWH
STW
Figure
6.3 Layout Plan of the Proposed
Sewage Treatment Works Extension in FLN NDA
Figure
6.4 Proposed Sewerage Layout
for Kwu Tung North NDA
Figure
6.5 Proposed Sewerage Layout
for Fanling North NDA
Figure 6.6 Proposed
Treated Sewage Effluent (TSE) Mains in Kwu Tung North NDA
Figure
6.7 Proposed Treated Sewage
Effluent (TSE) Mains in Fanling North NDA
Figure
6.8 Proposed Treated Sewage
Effluent (TSE) Mains within the Study Area
9 Hazard to Life
Figure 9.1 NDA development near Sheung Shui Water Treatment Works (SSWTW)
Figure 9.3 Societal Risk Guidelines
Figure 9.5 Major Construction Work within 1 km CZ of SSWTW
Figure 9.6 Site Layout of SSWTW
Figure 9.7 Topography around SSWTW
Figure 9.8 Locations of Roads and Railway Surrounding SSWTW
Figure 9.9 FN Curves for the Construction Stage
Figure 9.10 FN Curves for the Operation Stage
Figure 9.11 Breakdown of FN curves by Accident Type (Case 6: 2030 NDA + surrounding)
Figure 9.12 IR Contours for SSWTW
10 Landfill Gas Hazard
Figure 10.1 Location of Landfill Gas Consultation Zone within NENT NDAs
Figure 10.2 Ma Tso Lung Landfill Site and KTN NDA RODP
Figure 10.3 Drillholes in Ma Tso Lung Landfill for Landfill Gas Monitoring
Figure 10.4 Location of Surface Gas Monitoring in Ma Tso Lung Landfill
11 CULTURAL HERITAGE
Figure 11.1 Declared Monuments, Graded/Proposed Graded Historic Buildings and Sites of Archaeological Interest within the CHAA
Figure 11.3 Test Pits and Auger Holes Conducted in previous NENT Study
Figure 11.4 Areas and Spots of Archaeological Interest
Figure 11.5 Historic Buildings and Landscape Features in KTN NDA and Associated Infrastructure Works CHAA
Figure 11.8 Evaluation for Archaeological Potential and Significance for KTN NDA CHAA
Figure 11.9 Areas of Medium Archaeological Potential with No Survey Conduct before
Figure 11.10a Evaluation for Archaeological Potential and Significance for FLN NDA CHAA
Figure 11.10b Evaluation for Archaeological Potential and Significance for FLN NDA CHAA
12 Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment
Figure 12.0.0 Aerial photograph of Study Area (Key Plan)
Figure 12.0.1 Aerial photograph of the Study Area for Kwu Tung North (KTN) NDA
Figure 12.0.2.1 Aerial photograph of the Study Area for Fanling (FLN) NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.0.2.2 Aerial photograph of the Study Area for Fanling (FLN) NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.1.0 Existing Zonings within the Study Area for KTN NDA
Figure 12.2.0.1 Existing Zonings within the Study Area for FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.2.0.2 Existing Zonings within the Study Area for FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.5.0 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (Key Plan)
Figure 12.5.1 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (1 of 8)
Figure 12.5.2 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (2 of 8)
Figure 12.5.3 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (3 of 8)
Figure 12.5.4 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (4of 8)
Figure 12.5.5 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (5 of 8)
Figure 12.5.6 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (6 of 8)
Figure 12.5.7 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (7 of 8)
Figure 12.5.8 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (8 of 8)
Figure 12.5.9 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (1 of 12)
Figure 12.5.10 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (2 of 12)
Figure 12.5.11 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (3 of 12)
Figure 12.5.12 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (4 of 12)
Figure 12.5.13 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (5 of 12)
Figure 12.5.14 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (6 of 12)
Figure 12.5.15 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (7 of 12)
Figure 12.5.16 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (8 of 12)
Figure 12.5.17 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (9 of 12)
Figure 12.5.18 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (10 of 12)
Figure 12.5.19 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (11 of 12)
Figure 12.5.20 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) in KTN NDA Study Area (12 of 12)
Figure 12.6.0 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (Key Plan)
Figure 12.6.1 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (1 of 7)
Figure 12.6.2 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (2 of 7)
Figure 12.6.3 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (3 of 7)
Figure 12.6.4 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (4 of 7)
Figure 12.6.5 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (5 of 7)
Figure 12.6.6 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (6 of 7)
Figure 12.6.7 Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (7 of 7)
Figure 12.6.8 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (1 of 10)
Figures 12.6.9 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (2 of 10)
Figure 12.6.10 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (3 of 10)
Figure 12.6.11 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (4 of 10)
Figure 12.6.12 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (5 of 10)
Figure 12.6.13 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (6 of 10)
Figure 12.6.14 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (7 of 10)
Figure 12.6.15 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (8 of 10)
Figure 12.6.16 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (9 of 10)
Figure 12.6.17 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRS) in FLN NDA Study Area (10 of 10)
Figure 12.7.0 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (Key Plan)
Figure 12.7.1 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (1 of 8)
Figure 12.7.2 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (2 of 8)
Figure 12.7.3 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (3 of 8)
Figure 12.7.4 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (4 of 8)
Figure 12.7.5 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (5 of 8)
Figure 12.7.6 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (6 of 8)
Figure 12.7.7 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (7 of 8)
Figure 12.7.8 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (8 of 8)
Figure 12.7.9 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in KTN NDA Study Area (1 of 2)
Figure 12.7.10 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in KTN NDA Study Area (2 of 2)
Figure 12.8.0 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (Key Plan)
Figure 12.8.1 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (1 of 7)
Figure 12.8.2 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (2 of 7)
Figure 12.8.3 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (3 of 7)
Figure 12.8.4 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (4 of 7)
Figure 12.8.5 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (5 of 7)
Figure 12.8.6 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (6 of 7)
Figure 12.8.7 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (7 of 7)
Figure 12.8.8 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in FLN NDA Study Area (1 of 2)
Figure 12.8.9 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in FLN NDA Study Area (2 of 2)
Figure 12.9.0 RODP for KTN NDA
Figure 12.9.1 RODP Development Parameters in KTN NDA Study Area (1 of 2)
Figure 12.9.2 RODP Development Parameters in KTN NDA Study Area (2 of 2)
Figure 12.9.3 RODP for KTN NDA Highlighting Urban Planning Context of original RODP
Figure 12.9.4 RODP for KTN NDA Highlighting Planning Measures incorporated into RODP (1 of 2)
Figure 12.9.5 RODP for KTN NDA Highlighting Planning Measures incorporated into RODP (2 of 2)
Figure 12.10.0.1 RODP for FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.10.0.2 RODP for FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.10.1 RODP Development Parameters in FLN NDA Study Area (1 of 2)
Figure 12.10.2 RODP Development Parameters in FLN NDA Study Area (2 of 2)
Figure 12.10.3 RODP for FLN NDA Highlighting Urban Planning Context of original RODP
Figure 12.10.4 RODP for FLN NDA Highlighting Planning Measures incorporated into RODP (1 of 2)
Figure 12.10.5 RODP for FLN NDA Highlighting Planning Measures incorporated into RODP (2 of 2)
Figure 12.11.0 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (Key Plan)
Figure 12.11.1 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (1 of 4)
Figure 12.11.2 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (2 of 4)
Figure 12.11.3 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (3 of 4)
Figure 12.11.4 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (4 of 4)
Figure 12.11.5a Cut / Fill Contour Plan for KTN NDA
Figure 12.11.5b Cut / Fill Contour Plan for KTN NDA
Figure 12.11.5c Cut / Fill Contour Plan for KTN NDA
Figure 12.11.5d Cut / Fill Contour Plan for KTN NDA
Figure 12.11.6 Section Drawings of Water Service Reservoirs in KTN NDA
Figure 12.11.7 Topographic model of KTN Flushing and Fresh Water Service Reservoirs at G1-4 and G1-5
Figure 12.12.0 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (Key Plan)
Figure 12.12.1 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (1 of 4)
Figure 12.12.2 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (2 of 4)
Figure 12.12.3 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (3 of 4)
Figure 12.12.4 Impacts on Landscape Resources (LRs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (4 of 4)
Figure 12.12.5a Cut / Fill Contour Plan for FLN NDA
Figure 12.12.5b Cut / Fill Contour Plan for FLN NDA
Figure 12.12.5c Cut / Fill Contour Plan for FLN NDA
Figure 12.12.5d Cut / Fill Contour Plan for FLN NDA
Figure 12.12.6 Section Drawings of Fresh Water Service Reservoirs in FLN NDA
Figure 12.12.7 Section Drawings of Flushing Water Service Reservoirs in FLN NDA
Figure 12.12.8 Topographic model of FLN Fresh Water Service Reservoir at A3-1
Figure 12.12.9 Topographic model of FLN Flushing Water Service Reservoir at D4-1
Figure 12.13.0 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (Key Plan)
Figure 12.13.1 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (1 of 4)
Figure 12.13.2 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (2 of 4)
Figure 12.13.3 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (3 of 4)
Figure 12.13.4 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for KTN NDA (4 of 4)
Figure 12.14.0 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (Key Plan)
Figures 12.14.1 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (1 of 4)
Figures 12.14.2 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (2 of 4)
Figures 12.14.3 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (3 of 4)
Figures 12.14.4 Impacts on Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) in the Study Area for FLN NDA (4 of 4)
Figure 12.15.0 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Key Plan)
Figure 12.15.1 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom A)
Figure 12.15.2 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom B)
Figure 12.15.3 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom C)
Figure 12.15.4 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom D)
Figure 12.15.5 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom E)
Figure 12.15.6 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom F)
Figure 12.15.7 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom G)
Figure 12.16.0 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Key Plan)
Figure 12.16.1 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom A)
Figure 12.16.2 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom B)
Figure 12.16.3 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom C)
Figure 12.16.4 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom D)
Figure 12.16.5 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom E)
Figure 12.18.1 Primary Zone of Visual Influence for KTN NDA + VSR & VP Locations
Figure 12.19.1 Primary Zone of Visual Influence for FLN NDA + VSR & VP Locations
Figure 12.20.1 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K1 Ma Tso Lung San Tsuen
Figure 12.20.2.1 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K2a (F30) Tai Shek Mo Lookout
Figure 12.20.3 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K3 Western Ranges - Lok Ma Chau Footpath
Figure 12.20.4 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K4 Cottage Area (Western Ranges)
Figure 12.20.5.1 Existing View North from K5a Northern Knoll of Fung Kong Shan
Figure 12.20.5.2 Existing View South towards KTN NDA from K5a Northern Knoll of Fung Kong Shan
Figure 12.20.5.3 Existing View North towards KTN NDA from K5b Southern Knoll of Fung Kong Shan
Figure 12.20.5.4 Existing View South towards KTN NDA from K5b Southern Knoll of Fung Kong Shan
Figure 12.20.5.5 Existing View East towards KTN NDA from K5a/b Knoll of Fung Kong Shan
Figure 12.20.6.1 Existing View towards East within KTN NDA from K6a Ho Sheung Heung
Figure 12.20.6.2 Existing View South from within KTN NDA, at Southern K6b Ho Sheung Heung
Figure 12.20.7.1 Existing View West towards KTN NDA from K7a Tsung Yuen
Figure 12.20.10 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K10 Cycle track along riverside near Long Valley
Figure 12.20.12 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K12 Tsung Pak Long
Figure 12.20.13 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K13 Industrial Zone northeast of Tsung Pak Long
Figure 12.20.14 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K14 Tai Tau Leng
Figure 12.20.15 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K15 Choi Po Court / Choi Yuen Estate
Figure 12.20.16 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K16 Tai Ping Area High Rise Residential Blocks
Figure 12.20.17 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K17 Hong Kong Golf Club, Fanling
Figure 12.20.18 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K18 Ascot Park Area, Kam Tsin
Figure 12.20.20 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K20 Valais & Europa Garden
Figure 12.20.21 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K21 Kwu Tung Service Reservoir
Figure 12.20.22 Existing View towards KTN NDA and FLN NDA from K22 (F28) Ki Lun Shan Footpath
Figure 12.20.23 Existing View towards KTN NDA from K23 Chau Tau Village
Figure 12.21.1 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F1 Cottage Area Lining Fu Tei Au Road
Figure 12.21.2 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F2 Existing Settlements around Sheung Shui Wa Shan
Figure 12.21.3 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F3 Tsung Shan, High Hill
Figure 12.21.4 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F4 Siu Hang San Tsuen
Figure 12.21.5 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F5 Kan Lung Tsuen Area
Figure 12.21.6 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F6 Sha Tau Kok Road
Figure 12.21.7 Existing View towards FLN NDA & Eastern Fanling Bypass, from F7 Ma Wat Tsuen Area
Figure 12.21.8 Existing View towards FLN NDA & Eastern Fanling Bypass, from F8 Shung Him Tong
Figure 12.21.10 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F10 Po Kat Tsai
Figure 12.21.11 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F11 Belair Monte & Regentville
Figure 12.21.12 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F12 Wing Fai Centre & Wing Fok Centre
Figure 12.21.13 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F13 Fanling Garden
Figure 12.21.14 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F14 Good View New Village/ Ling Shan Tsuen
Figure 12.21.15 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F15 Noble Hill
Figure 12.21.16 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F16 Fanling Wai
Figure 12.21.17 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F17 North District Park
Figure 12.21.18 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F18 Ka Fuk Estate Area
Figure 12.21.19 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F19 On Kwok Villa
Figure 12.21.21 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F21 North District Sports Ground
Figure 12.21.22 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F22 Tsui Lai Garden
Figure 12.21.23 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F23 Fung Kai Area
Figure 12.21.24 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F24 Sheung Shui Wai Area
Figure 12.21.25 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F25 Industrial Zone SW of Sheung Shui Wai
Figure 12.21.26 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F26 (K6a) Ho Sheung Heung
Figure 12.21.27 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F27 Tsung Yuen
Figure 12.21.28 Existing View towards FLN NDA and KTN NDA from F28 (K22) Ki Lun Shan Footpath
Figure 12.21.29 Existing View towards FLN NDA from F29 Wu Tip Shan Lookout
Figure 12.22.1a Photomontage from K1 Ma Tso Lung San Tsuen, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.22.1b Photomontage from K1 Ma Tso Lung San Tsuen, looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.22.2.1a Photomontage from K2a(F30) Tai Shek Mo Lookout, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.22.2.1b Photomontage from K2a (F30) Tai Shek Mo Lookout, looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.22.4a Photomontage from K4 Cottage Area (Western Range), looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.22.4b Photomontage from K4 Cottage Area (Western Range), looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.22.7a Photomontage from K6b Ho Sheung Heung, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.22.7b Photomontage from K6b Ho Sheung Heung, looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.22.8a Photomontage from K7b Tsung Yuen, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.22.8b Photomontage from K7b Tsung Yuen, looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.22.11a Photomontage from K18 Ascot Park Area, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.22.11b Photomontage from K18 Ascot Park Area, looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.22.13a Photomontage from K22 Ki Lun Shan Footpath, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.22.13b Photomontage from K22 Ki Lun Shan Footpath, looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.22.14a Photomontage from K24 Kei Lak Tsai Footpath in Lam Tsuen Country Park, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.1a Photomontage from F2 Existing Settlements around Sheung Shui Wa Shan, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.2a Photomontage from F3 Tsung Shan, High Hill, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.2b Photomontage from F3 Tsung Shan, High Hill, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.3a Photomontage from F5 Kan Lung Tsuen Area, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.3b Photomontage from F5 Kan Lung Tsuen Area, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.4a Photomontage from F7 Ma Wat Tsuen Area, looking towards FLN NDA (1of 2)
Figure 12.23.4b Photomontage from F7 Ma Wat Tsuen Area, looking towards FLN NDA (2of 2)
Figure 12.23.5a Photomontage from F11 Belair Monte & Regentville, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.5b Photomontage from F11 Belair Monte & Regentville, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.7a Photomontage from F15 Noble Hill, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.7b Photomontage from F15 Noble Hill, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.8a Photomontage from F16 Fanling Wai, looking West towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.8b Photomontage from F16 Fanling Wai, looking West towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.9a Photomontage from F17 North District Park, looking West towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.9b Photomontage from F17 North District Park, looking West towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.12a Photomontage from F24 Sheung Shui Wai Area, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.12b Photomontage from F24 Sheung Shui Wai Area, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.13a Photomontage from F26 (K6) Ho Sheung Heung, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.13b Photomontage from F26 (K6) Ho Sheung Heung, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.14a Photomontage from F28 (K22) Ki Lun Shan, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.14b Photomontage from F28 (K22) Ki Lun Shan, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.15a Photomontage from F29 Wu Tip Shan Lookout, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.23.15b Photomontage from F29 Wu Tip Shan Lookout, looking towards FLN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.23.16a Photomontage from F30 (K2) Tai Shek Mo Footpath & Lookout, looking towards FLN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.50.1 Planning and Development Control Framework Schedule 2 DP 1, 2, 3 and 4
Figure 12.50.2 Planning and Development Control Framework - Schedule 2 DP 5
Figure 12.50.3 Planning and Development Control Framework - Schedule 2 DP 7, 11 and 13
Figure 12.50.4 Planning and Development Control Framework - Schedule 2 DP 8, 9, 10 and 12
Figure 12.51.1 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) Key Plan
Figure 12.51.2 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (5) Key Plan
Figure 12.51.3 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) Key Plan
Figure 12.51.4 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) Key Plan
Figure 12.51.5 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) (sheet 1 of 6)
Figure 12.51.6 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) (sheet 2 of 6)
Figure 12.51.7 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) (sheet 3 of 6)
Figure 12.51.8 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) (sheet 4 of 6)
Figure 12.51.9 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) (sheet 5 of 6)
Figure 12.51.10 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) (sheet 6 of 6)
Figure 12.51.11 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (5) (sheet 1 of 2)
Figure 12.51.12 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (5) (sheet 2 of 2)
Figure 12.51.13 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) (sheet 1 of 6)
Figure 12.51.14 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) (sheet 2 of 6)
Figure 12.51.15 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) (sheet 3 of 6)
Figure 12.51.16 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) (sheet 4 of 6)
Figure 12.51.17 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) (sheet 5 of 6)
Figure 12.51.18 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) (sheet 6 of 6)
Figure 12.51.19 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 1 of 9)
Figure 12.51.20 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 2 of 9)
Figure 12.51.21 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 3 of 9)
Figure 12.51.22 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 4 of 9)
Figure 12.51.23 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 5 of 9)
Figure 12.51.24 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 6 of 9)
Figure 12.51.25 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 7 of 9)
Figure 12.51.26 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 8 of 9)
Figure 12.51.27 Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) (sheet 9 of 9)
Figure 12.51.30 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.31 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.32 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.33 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.34 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.35 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.36 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.37 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.38 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.39 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.40 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.41 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.51.42 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (DP 5)
Figure 12.51.43 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (DP 5)
Figure 12.51.44 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (DP 5)
Figure 12.51.45 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (DP 5)
Figure 12.51.46 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package B (DP 5)
Figure 12.51.47 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.48 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.49 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.50 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.51 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.52 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.53 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.54 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.55 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.56 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.51.57 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.58 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.59 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.60 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.61 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.62 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.63 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.64 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.65 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.66 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.51.67 Photographs of Landscape Resources (LRs) DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.52.1 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.52.2 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) DP Package B (5)
Figure 12.52.3 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) DP Package C (7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.52.4 Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) Key Plan
Figure 12.52.5 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package A (DP 1, 2 ,3 and 4)
Figure 12.52.6 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package A (DP 1, 2, 3 and 4)
Figure 12.52.7 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package B (DP 5)
Figure 12.52.8 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package B (DP 5)
Figure 12.52.9 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.52.10 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package C (DP 7, 11 and 13)
Figure 12.52.11 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.52.12 Photographs of Landscape Character Areas (LCAs) – DP Package D (DP 8, 9, 10 and 12)
Figure 12.52.20 Impact on Landscape Resources DP Package A (1, 2, 3 and 4) Key Plan
Figure 12.52.21 Impact on Landscape Resources DP Package B (5) Key Plan
Figure 12.52.22 Impact on Landscape Resources DP Package C (7, 11 and 13) Key Plan
Figure 12.52.23 Impact on Landscape Resources - DP Package D (8, 9, 10 and 12) Key Plan
Figure 12.52.24 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 1 (sheet 1 of 3)
Figure 12.52.25 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 1 (sheet 2 of 3)
Figure 12.52.26 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 1 (sheet 3 of 3)
Figure 12.52.27 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 2 (sheet 1 of 2)
Figure 12.52.28 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 2 (sheet 2 of 2)
Figure 12.52.29 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 3 (sheet 1 of 1)
Figure 12.52.30 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 4 (sheet 1 of 2)
Figure 12.52.31 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 4 (sheet 2 of 2)
Figure 12.52.32 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 5 (sheet 1 of 1)
Figure 12.52.33 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 7 (sheet 1 of 2)
Figure 12.52.36 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 7 (sheet 2 of 2)
Figure 12.52.37 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 8 (sheet 1 of 1)
Figure 12.52.38 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 9 (sheet 1 of 1)
Figure 12.52.39 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 10 (sheet 1 of 3)
Figure 12.52.40 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 10 (sheet 2 of 3)
Figure 12.52.41 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 10 (sheet 3 of 3)
Figure 12.52.34 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 11 (sheet 1 of 1)
Figure 12.52.42 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 12 (sheet 1 of 1)
Figure 12.52.35 Impact on Landscape Resources DP 13 (sheet 1 of 1)
Figure 12.52.50 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Key Plan)
Figure 12.52.51 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom A)
Figure 12.52.52 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom B)
Figure 12.52.53 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom C)
Figure 12.52.54 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom D)
Figure 12.52.55 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom E)
Figure 12.52.56 KTN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom F)
Figure 12.52.61 Zoom In Plan for Proposed KTN Sewage Pumping Station (SPS) South of Ho Sheung Heung
Figure 12.52.62 Zoom In Plan for Proposed KTN Sewage Pumping Station (SPS) South of Ma Tso Lung
Figure 12.52.70 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Key Plan)
Figure 12.52.71 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom A)
Figure 12.52.72 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom B)
Figure 12.52.73 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom C)
Figure 12.52.74 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom D)
Figure 12.52.75 FLN NDA Landscape Mitigation Plan (Zoom E)
Figure 12.52.81 Sections for Po Shek Wu Interchange Improvement (Sheet 1 of 2)
Figure 12.52.82 Sections for Po Shek Wu Interchange Improvement (Sheet 2 of 2)
Figure 12.52.84 Sections for Fanling Bypass (Sheet 1 of 3)
Figure 12.52.85 Sections for Fanling Bypass (Sheet 2 of 3)
Figure 12.52.86 Sections for Fanling Bypass (Sheet 3 of 3)
Figure 12.52.87 Sections for Proposed Expansion and Upgrading of Sewage Treatment Works
Figure 12.52.88 Sections for Proposed Expansion and Upgrading of Sewage Treatment Works
Figure 12.52.91 Zoom In Plan for Proposed FLN Sewage Pumping Station (SPS) Off Man Kam To Road
Figure 12.52.92 Zoom In Plan for Proposed FLN Sewage Pumping Station (SPS) South of Wa Shan
Figure 12.52.93 Zoom In Plan for Proposed FLN Sewage Pumping Station (SPS) Opposite Sacred Hill
Figure 12.52.94 Zoom In Plan for Proposed FLN Sewage Pumping Station (SPS) South of Fu Tei Au
Figure 12.53.1 Vantage Point (VP) Locations - Schedule 2 DP 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 7.
Figure 12.53.2 Vantage Point (VP) Locations - Schedule 2 DP 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12.
Figure 12.53.3 K VP 1a – Highpoint above Pak Shek Au, facing south
Figure 12.53.4 K VP 1b – Highpoint above Pak Shek Au, facing northeast
Figure 12.53.5 K VP 2 (K22) – Ki Lun Shan Footpath
Figure 12.53.6 K VP 3 – Pedestrian bridge over Fanling Highway, near Kam Tsin
Figure 12.53.7 K VP 4 (K18) – Ascot Park Area
Figure 12.53.8 K VP 5 (K16) – Residential tower, Tai Ping Estate
Figure 12.53.9 K VP 6 (K15) – Residential tower – Choi Po Court / Choi Yuen Estate
Figure 12.53.10 K VP 7 (K13) – Industrial area, northeast of Tsung Pak Long
Figure 12.53.11 K VP 8 – Ying Kong Village
Figure 12.53.12 K VP 9 (K6b) – Ho Sheung Heung Village
Figure 12.53.13 K VP 10 – Southern Knoll of Fung Kong Shan, facing north
Figure 12.53.14 K VP 11 (K4) – Cottage Area (Western Range)
Figure 12.53.15 K VP 12 – Ma Tso Lung Shun Yee San Tsuen Village
Figure 12.54.1 F VP 1 – Po Shek Wu Road adjacent Tai Tau Leng
Figure 12.54.2 F VP 2 – Residential tower, Choi Po Court, Choi Ying House
Figure 12.54.3 F VP 3 – Pedestrian footbridge, San Wan Road
Figure 12.54.4 F VP 4 – Corner of San Wan Road and San Po Street
Figure 12.54.5 FVP 5 – Chuk Wan Street adjacent Shek Wu Hui Sewage Treatment works
Figure 12.54.6 F VP 6a – Highpoint above Fu Tei Au Tseun, facing south
Figure 12.54.7 F VP 6b – Highpoint above Fu Tei Au Tseun, facing east
Figure 12.54.8 F VP 7 – Jockey Club Road, adjacent Ha Pak Tsuen
Figure 12.54.9 F VP 8 – Access road adjacent Ng Tung River, west of Wa Shan Tsuen
Figure 12.54.10 F VP 9 – Access track, Sheung Shui Wa Shan
Figure 12.54.11 F VP 10 – Access road, south of Sheung Shui Wa Shan
Figure 12.54.12 F VP 11 – Sitting out area adjacent road bridge over Ng Tung River
Figure 12.54.13 F VP 12 – Lung Sum Avenue adjacent Woodland Crest
Figure 12.54.14 F VP 13 (F20) – Residential block within Tin Ping Estate
Figure 12.54.15 F VP 14 – Footbridge north of Wu Nga Lok Yeung
Figure 12.54.16 F VP 15 (F4) from Siu Hang San Tsuen
Figure 12.54.17 F VP 16 – Residential Block Belair Monte & Regentville
Figure 12.54.18 F VP 17 – Bridge over Ma Wat River, Sha Tau Road
Figure 12.54.19 F VP 18 – Road junction west of Wing Ning Wai & Wing Ning Tsuen
Figure 12.54.20 F VP 19 – Agricultural plots, Ma Wat Wai
Figure 12.54.21 F VP 20 (F8) – Access road, Shung Him Tong
Figure 12.54.22 F VP 21 – Highpoint within On Lok Tsuen
Figure 12.54.23 F VP 22 – Bus stop, Cyber Domaine residential estate
Figure 12.54.24 F VP 23 – Pedestrian footbridge, Kau Lung Hang San Wai
Figure 12.54.25 F VP 24 – Wo Hing Road, Wo Hop Shek Village
Figure 12.54.26 F VP 25 – Residential Block, Wah Sum Estate
Figure 12.55.1a Photomontage from K VP 2 Ki Lun Shan Footpath, looking towards KTN NDA (1 of 2)
Figure 12.55.1b Photomontage from K VP 2 Ki Lun Shan Footpath, looking towards KTN NDA (2 of 2)
Figure 12.55.2b Photomontage from K VP4 Ascot Park Area, looking towards KTN Schedule 2 DPs (2 of 2)
Figure 12.55.8a Photomontage from F VP2 Choi Po Court, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (1 of 2)
Figure 12.55.8b Photomontage from F VP2 Choi Po Court, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (2 of 2)
Figure 12.55.9a Photomontage from F VP6a Fu Tei Au, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (1 of 2)
Figure 12.55.9b Photomontage from F VP6a Fu Tei Au, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (2 of 2)
Figure 12.55.10a Photomontage from F VP6b Fu Tei Au, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (1 of 2)
Figure 12.55.10b Photomontage from F VP6b Fu Tei Au, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (2 of 2)
Figure 12.55.15a Photomontage from F VP18 Wing Ling Wai, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (1 of 2)
Figure 12.55.15b Photomontage from F VP18 Wing Ling Wai, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (2 of 2)
Figure 12.55.17a Photomontage from F VP22 Tong Hang, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (1 of 2)
Figure 12.55.17b Photomontage from F VP22 Tong Hang, looking towards FLN Schedule 2 DPs (2 of 2)
13 Ecological Impact Assessment
Figure 13.1 Study Area and NDA Boundaries and Sites of Conservation Significance in the Surrounding Area
Figure 13.2 Non-bird Fauna Survey Coverage in the Study Area
Figure 13.3 Bird Survey Coverage in the Study Area
Figure 13.4 Shek Sheung, Ng Tung and Sheung Yue Rivers: Hydrological Conditions and Transect Routes
Figure 13.5 a Habitats in the Study Area – Key Plan
Figure 13.5 b-v Habitats in the Study Area (Page 1-21)
Figure 13.7 Findings of Egretry Flight-line Survey at Ho Sheung Heung
Figure 13.8 Findings of Egretry Flight-line Survey at Man Kam To Road
Figure 13.9 a-c Watercourses in the Study Area (Page 1-3)
Figure 13.10 a-c Ecological Evaluation of Plantations in the Study Area (Page 1-3)
Figure 13.12 a-b Areas Protected from Development by the NDA Proposed Zonings (Page1-2)
Figure 13.13 Habitats within the Proposed Long Valley Nature Park Boundary
Figure 13.14 a-c Areas of Wetland and Woodland Loss and Proposed Compensatory Planting (Page1-3)
Figure 13.16a Indicative Cross Section of Riparian Corridor at Ma Tso Lung Stream Following Diversion and Restoration
Figure 13.17a-b Watercourses of Ecological Importance and Proposed Buffers (Page 1-2)
Figure 13.18a-c Habitats in the Study Area showing the Footprint of the Project Area (Page 1-3)
14 Fisheries Impact Assessment
Figure 14.1 Current Status of Fish Ponds in KTN NDA Assessment Area
Figure 14.2 Current Status of Fish Ponds in FLN NDA
Figure 14.3 Construction and Operational Phase Impacts to Fisheries in KTN NDA
Figure 14.4 Construction and Operational Phase Impacts to Fisheries in FLN NDA
Figure 14.5 Potential sites for relocation of the fish fry farm from Fung Kong
16 Summary of Environment Outcomes
Figure 16.1 Minor Changes in Revised KTN NDA RODP
Figure 16.2 Minor Changes in Revised FLN NDA RODP