11.              CONCLUSION AND SUMMARY OF ENVIRONMENTAL OUTCOMES

 

11.1          Introduction

 

11.1.1     This Section summarises the environmental outcomes associated with the construction and operation of the Improvement of Yuen Long Town Nullah – Town Centre Section.

 

11.2          Environmental Benefits of the Project

 

11.2.1     Under this Project, the polluted DWF to the nullah will be intercepted and treated in the YLEPP. Upon completion of the DWFI system under the Project, the residents living along the Town Centre Section of YLTN will be immediately benefited from the elimination of odour problem due to polluted DWF. In addition, by intercepting the polluted DWF for proper treatment, the downstream ecologically sensitive Shan Pui River and Inner Deep Bay will be benefited by the improved water quality.

 

11.2.2     Further descriptions of the environmental outcomes of the Project are presented in the following sections.

 

11.3          Air Quality

 

11.3.1     The potential sources of air quality impacts associated with the construction and operation of the Project have been identified and the potential impacts were evaluated.

 

11.3.2     Construction works of the Project will inevitably generate some fugitive dust, especially during the excavation of the YLTN.  With the sectioning construction approach, the areas of excavation works should be limited in scale.  Regular water spraying will also help to control dust nuisance.

 

11.3.3     Through proper implementation of dust control measures required under the Air Pollution Control (Construction Dust) Regulation, construction fugitive dust should be controlled at source to satisfactory levels. 

 

11.3.4     Maintenance works for the Project will be small-scale in nature.  During the operation phase, the Project will unlikely cause any unacceptable air quality impacts in terms of dust and odour.  In addition, it is expected that odour nuisance of the YLTN will be alleviated due to operation of the Project since the polluted DWF originally discharged into the Project Site will be diverted to the YLEPP.  This is being considered as a beneficial impact of the Project.

 

11.3.5     Cumulative air quality impacts associated with concurrent projects within the Study Area have been considered, no unacceptable cumulative impacts are anticipated with adoption of mitigation measures.

 

11.3.6     With the implementation of the recommended mitigation measures, it is expected that the residual impacts from the construction and operation of the Project will not exceed any relevant air quality criteria.  As such no unacceptable residual air quality impacts are envisaged from the construction and operation of the Project.

 

11.3.7     In order to ensure and demonstrate that mitigation measures are properly implemented during the construction stage for reducing the air quality impacts from the Project, weekly site inspections and audits as well as odour monitoring will be conducted as part of the EM&A Programme of the Project.

 

11.4          Noise

 

11.4.1    A construction noise assessment has been undertaken to predict the noise levels at the representative NSRs due to the construction of the Project.  Practicable mitigation measures, including use of quiet construction plant, noise barriers, noise insulation sheet and scheduling of construction activities, have been recommended.  With the implementation of the recommended mitigation measures, the predicted construction noise levels at all NSRs comply with the noise criteria during the daytime period.  Therefore, no unacceptable noise impact is expected to arise from the construction activities.  Also, no unacceptable cumulative impact or residual impact is anticipated.  Regular noise monitoring at NSRs as part of the EM&A programme during the construction stage is recommended. 

 

11.4.2    Potential noise impact from the operation of the proposed DWF pumping station has been assessed.  The predicted fixed plant noise levels at the representative NSRs due to the operation of the proposed DWF pumping station and the cumulative noise levels with the operation of the existing pumping stations comply with the day-time and night-time noise criteria.  No unacceptable residual impact is anticipated.  Attenuation measures, if required, will be provided to the fixed plant items for achieving the compliance of EIAO-TM noise criteria during the detailed design stage.

 

11.5          Water Quality

 

11.5.1    The potential sources of water quality impacts associated with the construction and operation of the Project have been identified and the potential impacts were evaluated. 

 

11.5.2    Potential impacts arising from the proposed construction works are predicted to be largely confined to the specific works areas.  With proper implementation of the recommended mitigation measures, in particular the establishment of dry condition for excavation works within the existing nullah and adoption of good construction site practices as recommended in relevant regulatory guidelines, unacceptable water quality impacts are not expected at the identified WSRs including the Deep Bay Wetland Conservation Area and Mai Po Inner Deep Bay Ramsar Site. 

 

11.5.3    During the operation phase, the interception of polluted DWF by the Project is expected to lead to improvement of water quality within the YLTN and at Shan Pui River and is thus considered to be beneficial.  With regular maintenance works to remove excessive sediments, it is anticipated that the Project will not lead to any unacceptable water quality impacts by altering the sediment deposition and erosion pattern of the Project Site and its downstream area.  Unacceptable water quality impacts are also not expected to occur at any identified WSRs including the Deep Bay Wetland Conservation Area and Mai Po Inner Deep Bay Ramsar Site due to the small-scale and infrequent maintenance works. 

 

11.5.4    During emergency discharge of the collected DWF to the YLTN (e.g. due to breakdown of the DWF pumping station), water quality of the nullah is predicted to be similar to the existing condition before operation of the Project.  In addition, given the low likelihood of the emergency discharge and proper Emergency Response Plan will be in place and implemented, no unacceptable water quality impact is expected to be associated with such discharge.

 

11.5.5    With proper implementation of the recommended mitigation measures, it is expected that the residual impacts from the construction and operation of the Project will not exceed any relevant water quality criteria.  As such, no unacceptable residual water quality impacts are envisaged from the construction and operation of the Project.  Nevertheless, a monitoring programme is recommended during the construction phase to verify the predictions of the EIA and ensure compliance with the assessment criteria.

 

11.5.6    Cumulative water quality impacts associated with concurrent projects within the Study Area have been considered with no unacceptable impact anticipated.

 

11.6          Waste Management and Land Contamination

 

11.6.1    Wastes generated by the construction activities are likely to include C&D materials from the construction works, general refuse from the workforce and chemical waste from any maintenance of construction plant and equipment.   Provided that these identified wastes arisen are handled, transported and disposed of using approved methods and that the recommended good site practices are strictly followed in terms of the avoidance-minimisation-reuse-recycling-disposal hierarchy, unacceptable environmental impacts are not anticipated during construction of the Project.

.  

11.6.2    The recommended measures can be enforced by incorporating them into the waste management requirements in the WMP as part of the EMP.  Environmental site audit would be necessary to ensure the implementation of proper waste management practices during construction.

 

11.6.3    For the operation phase, only silt material and debris are expected to be produced by maintenance works of the DWFI system.  Such waste will be removed by manual means and disposed of immediately after the clearance works.  Small amount of screenings and chemical waste will be generated during operation and routine maintenance of the DWF pumping station. No unacceptable environmental impacts are anticipated with proper waste management practices.

 

11.6.4    A review of past and present land uses of the Project site was conducted. Based on desk-top review and site walkover, the presence of contaminated land is not expected.

 

11.7          Ecology

 

11.7.1    A literature review and ecological field surveys have been conducted.  The ecological resources recorded within the Study Area included ten habitats (agricultural land, channelized watercourse, developed area, shrubland, mangrove, plantation, pond, reedbed, semi-natural watercourse and tidal marsh) of which two occurred in the Project Site (i.e. channelized watercourse and developed area). Total of 1 floral species and 44 faunal species of conservation importance have been identified within the 500m Study Area. Among them, four bird species were recorded within the Project Area.

 

11.7.2    Given that construction works is temporary in nature and of relatively small scale, and all the construction works will be confined within the channelized watercourse and developed area with low ecological values, with the implementation of the proposed avoidance/mitigation measures such as scheduling the construction of rising main within WBA outside dry season, implementation of mitigation measures for water quality control as detailed in Section 6.7 and good site practices, unacceptable adverse ecological impact is thus not anticipated during construction.

 

11.7.3    Unacceptable ecological impacts are also not anticipated during operation of the Project given the small-scale and temporary nature of the maintenance works as well as the small percentage of reduction in freshwater input to Shan Pui River due to the DWF interception. The ecological sensitives areas and wildlife at downstream could be potentially benefited from the improvement of water quality of Shan Pui River and Inner Deep Bay.

 

11.8          Landscape and Visual Impact

 

11.8.1    A Landscape Impact Assessment was undertaken for the construction and operation of the proposed Project in Yuen Long Town Centre.  Landscape mitigation measures were proposed as appropriate and residual landscape impacts have been identified.  With proper implementation of mitigation measures, all affected LRs and LCAs will have “slight” to “insignificant” adverse landscape impacts during construction phase and “insignificant” or even no impact at both Day 1 and Year 10 the operation. 

 

11.8.2    A Visual Impact Assessment was also undertaken and VSRs were identified and assessed based on their sensitivity and magnitude of change.  Visual mitigation measures were proposed as appropriate and residual visual impacts identified.  All VSRs will experience from “moderate” to “insignificant” visual impacts during construction phase after adoption of mitigation measures. At Year 10 of operation, T2 and T3 will receive “moderate” visual impacts arising from the proposed DWF pumping station while the remaining VSRs will receive nil or “insignificant” visual impacts. 

 

11.8.3    Landscape and Visual Impacts are considered acceptable with mitigation. 

 

11.9          EM&A Requirement

 

11.9.1    Monitoring of air quality (odour), noise and water quality has been recommended at designated sensitive receivers during the construction phase of the Project.  Environmental site audit should be conducted weekly throughout the construction phase to ensure that the proposed mitigation measures are implemented.

 

11.10      Overall Conclusion

 

11.10.1The environmental impact assessment has concluded that no unacceptable environmental impacts are envisaged as a result of the construction and operation of the Project, provided that the recommended mitigation measures are implemented.  In addition, through interception of the polluted DWF for treatment at the YLEPP, it is expected that the odour nuisance at the Town Centre Section of YLTN will be alleviated with an overall improvement in water quality during operation of the Project.

 

END OF TEXT