Press Releases

Press Releases - 2000

Service at refuse transfer station partially disrupted by Greenpeace's protest

The normal waste handling operation at the Island West Transfer Station (IWTS) of the Environmental Protection Department (EPD) has been partially disrupted by Greenpeace's protest today (March 23).

At about 1 pm today, protesters from Greenpeace's Rainbow Warrior stormed the IWTS in Kennedy Town. About 30 of their volunteers climbed on board a waste container vessel and staged a sit-in.

A spokesman for the EPD said: "Had they been protesting against the nearby old incinerator in Kennedy Town 10 years ago, we would have understood.

"This incinerator was closed down six years ago as part of our drive for a modern, environmentally acceptable waste management system."

The spokesman said: "The public can rest assured that the 500 tonnes of municipal waste which are normally delivered to the transfer station each day are still being handled in an environmentally sound manner."

The spokesman noted that at present Hong Kong did not incinerate any refuse at all, contrary to an agency report which said today that the protest was aimed at "Hong Kong's use of incinerators to dispose of much of the territory's refuse".

"We do incinerate a certain amount of chemical waste which cannot be safely treated by other processes, and plan to modify the plant to deal with about seven tonnes a day of clinical waste that cannot be safely treated by other means.

"Such treatment systems are essential to reduce human and environmental risks from chemicals and pathogens.

"The incinerator at the Chemical Waste Treatment Centre on Tsing Yi Island operates under the toughest regulatory standards available in the world with respect to dioxin and other emissions."

On exploring the use of waste-to-energy incineration, the spokesman said studies are being conducted and the public will be consulted. No views have been formed on the issue and it is too early to talk about site selection.

He reiterated that it was the government policy to manage waste through a programme of prevention, reduction, separation and recycling, followed by safe treatment and disposal.

"We are actively promoting waste reduction, separation and recovery of recyclables from the waste stream, including wastes from households, commercial and industrial sectors and the construction industry.

"However, even if we can recover all the recyclable waste in our waste stream, we will still end up with a significant quantity of non-recyclable waste that needs to be disposed of in a safe and environmentally sound manner.

"Landfilling and waste-to-energy incineration using the latest technologies and the highest standards will ensure that the waste that cannot be avoided and recycled will be handled properly to safeguard health of the community," he said.

It is impractical to think we can reuse and recycle all the waste we produce. Even Greenpeace does not recycle all its waste.

About 10 tonnes of oil waste from the Rainbow Warrior has been taken to the Chemical Waste Treatment Centre for treatment for use as incinerator fuel and three cubic metres of general rubbish was collected by marine services for disposal in Hong Kong's landfills.

Whilst the EPD shares Greenpeace's concern on issues such as the need to control persistent organic pollutants, promote clean industry, enhance waste recovery and recycling, the EPD is very concerned that Greenpeace's action has often done the opposite in misleading the public in understanding some key environmental issues.

For instance, it chooses to misquote the scientific findings of other researchers by 1 000 times in the report they released recently.

The concentration of DDT in Hong Kong coastal sediments should be 0.27 to 14.8 ng/g dry weight (dry wt), and not 300 to 14 800 ng/g dry wt as reported by Greenpeace to the media and the public.

As for HCHs, the figures should be 0.1 to 16.7 ng/g dry wt rather than 100 to 16 700 ng/g dry wt.

The spokesman said: "It seems odd that Greenpeace's purpose today is simply to get a meeting with senior officials from the Environment and Food Bureau.

"Senior officers from the EPD have been standing by all afternoon to discuss the issues with them but Greenpeace has refused to talk to these senior government representatives.

"The Secretary for the Environment and Food has met with green groups, including Greenpeace, before assuming office and in recent months."

Officers of the Administration will be pleased to exchange views with green groups on environmental issues through the normal channels, the spokesman added.

End/Thursday, March 23, 2000

 

Back to topdot_clear.gifTable of Content