| Summary of Main Model Runs |
|
|
|
%RSP |
|
|
|
%vkt |
%NOx |
%VOC |
(Tailpipe) |
(Road Dust) |
Composite |
| Year |
Run No. |
Description |
relative to 1997 |
relative to 1997 |
relative to 1997 |
relative to 1997 |
relative to 1997 |
Air Score |
| 2001 |
39 (98 KB) |
LOW / Toll Scheme A |
121% |
102% |
105% |
77% |
124% |
1.02 |
| 2001 |
40 (97 KB) |
LOW / Toll Scheme B |
121% |
102% |
105% |
77% |
124% |
1.02 |
| 2001 |
41 (96 KB) |
LOW / Toll Scheme C |
121% |
102% |
105% |
77% |
124% |
1.01 |
| 2001 |
43 (96 KB) |
LOW / Toll Scheme D1 |
121% |
102% |
105% |
77% |
123% |
1.01 |
| 2001 |
47 (95 KB) |
LOW / Toll Scheme D |
121% |
104% |
105% |
79% |
126% |
1.02 |
| 2001 |
48 (96 KB) |
LOW / Budget Toll |
191% |
102% |
103% |
78% |
123% |
1.01 |
| 2006 |
49 (96 KB) |
High Car High Goods |
147% |
92% |
102% |
56% |
148% |
0.96 |
| 2006 |
50 (96 KB) |
Medium Car High Goods |
141% |
90% |
97% |
56% |
148% |
0.94 |
| 2006 |
52 (97 KB) |
High Car Medium Goods |
145% |
89% |
100% |
54% |
152% |
0.93 |
| 2006 |
54 (97 KB) |
Medium Car Medium Goods |
138% |
88% |
95% |
54% |
153% |
0.92 |
| 2006 |
58 (95 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 1 |
147% |
92% |
102% |
57% |
149% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
75 (99 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System 2 w/o Route 7 |
148% |
92% |
102% |
57% |
149% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
76 (97 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2 |
150% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
150% |
0.98 |
| 2006 |
77 (98 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o CKR |
150% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
150% |
0.98 |
| 2006 |
78 (98 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o Route 9 |
150% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
150% |
0.98 |
| 2006 |
80 (98 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o IEC |
149% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
150% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
81 (98 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o T2 |
149% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
150% |
0.98 |
| 2006 |
82 (99 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o Route 5 |
150% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
150% |
0.98 |
| 2006 |
83 (98 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o Route 10 |
150% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
151% |
0.98 |
| 2006 |
84 (107 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o Route 16 |
149% |
93% |
102% |
57% |
149% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
85 (99 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o WCR & Cross Bay Link |
149% |
93% |
102% |
57% |
150% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
86 (97 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o all |
148% |
93% |
102% |
57% |
151% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
89 (99 KB) |
Scenario 2, Toll D, HVF, System Test 2, w/o TM Southern Bypass & Port Expressway |
149% |
93% |
102% |
57% |
149% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
91 (97 KB) |
Base Case for Rail Priority |
149% |
93% |
103% |
57% |
150% |
0.98 |
| 2006 |
92 (96 KB) |
Low Car, Toll B |
142% |
91% |
98% |
57% |
151% |
0.96 |
| 2006 |
94 (95 KB) |
Rail Priority |
149% |
92% |
102% |
57% |
149% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
95 (97 KB) |
Base Case |
147% |
91% |
100% |
56% |
146% |
0.95 |
| 2006 |
97 (97 KB) |
(Sc I, Lo, Toll D) Least Demand |
133% |
84% |
91% |
52% |
137% |
0.88 |
| 2006 |
98 (97 KB) |
System Test 2 without TKO Rail Phase II |
149% |
93% |
102% |
57% |
150% |
0.97 |
| 2006 |
102 (13 KB) |
2001 Road / 2006 Rail |
144% |
89% |
99% |
54% |
144% |
0.94 |
| 2006 |
106 (13 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - High Growth |
147% |
91% |
101% |
56% |
146% |
0.95 |
| 2006 |
107 (13 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - Medium Growth |
139% |
88% |
95% |
54% |
141% |
0.91 |
| 2011 |
41 (97 KB) |
High Car High Goods |
184% |
90% |
101% |
48% |
182% |
0.99 |
| 2011 |
42 (98 KB) |
Medium Car High Goods |
166% |
87% |
92% |
47% |
182% |
0.95 |
| 2011 |
43 (97 KB) |
Medium Car Medium Goods |
158% |
81% |
87% |
44% |
166% |
0.88 |
| 2011 |
44 (96 KB) |
High Car Medium Goods |
176% |
85% |
96% |
45% |
167% |
0.93 |
| 2011 |
55 (96 KB) |
PT Fare Policy |
186% |
91% |
101% |
48% |
183% |
1.00 |
| 2011 |
69 (96 KB) |
Sc II, Toll D, Hi, Base |
182% |
89% |
99% |
47% |
179% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
69p (96 KB) |
Park and Ride |
182% |
89% |
99% |
47% |
179% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
71 (97 KB) |
(SC I, Toll D, Lo) Least Demand |
153% |
79% |
84% |
43% |
163% |
0.86 |
| 2011 |
74 (98 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll D, Hi) System Test 4 |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
179% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
75 (98 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll B, Hi) System Test 4 |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
76 (99 KB) |
System Test 4 without IWC |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
77 (98 KB) |
System Test 4 without Central Wanchai Bypass |
182% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
78 (97 KB) |
System Test 4 without Lantau P1 road |
182% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
179% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
79 (97 KB) |
System Test 4 without IEC |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
80 (97 KB) |
System Test 4 without East-West Link |
182% |
89% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
81 (96 KB) |
System Test 4 without Lantau Road Link |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
82 (96 KB) |
System Test 4 without Eastern Highway |
182% |
89% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
83 (99 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll D, Hi) System Test 4 without HK-Lautau Link |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
183% |
0.99 |
| 2011 |
84 (99 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll B, Hi) System Test 4 (EHX - Toll D) |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
179% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
87 (98 KB) |
System Test 4 without North Hong Kong Line (Central to North Point) |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
88 (98 KB) |
System Test 4 without West Hong Kong Line (Sheung Wan to Green Island) |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
89 (99 KB) |
System Test 4 without Hung Hom to Wan Chai (KCRC) |
183% |
90% |
100% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
90 (108 KB) |
System Test 4 without East Kowloon Line (Tai Wai to Hung Hom) |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
93 (97 KB) |
PT Fare Integration |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2011 |
97 (99 KB) |
with 2001 Road/ 2006 Rail |
169% |
85% |
92% |
46% |
175% |
0.93 |
| 2011 |
103 (13 KB) |
High Xboder Case |
189% |
93% |
103% |
50% |
189% |
1.02 |
| 2011 |
104 (13 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - High Growth |
184% |
91% |
100% |
48% |
183% |
0.99 |
| 2011 |
105 (13 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - Medium Growth |
160% |
82% |
88% |
44% |
169% |
0.89 |
| 2011 |
106 (13 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll D, Hi) System Test 4 with Port Rail |
182% |
88% |
98% |
47% |
174% |
0.96 |
| 2011 |
107 (13 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll D, Hi) System Test 4 without Rail between Tai Wai and Diamond Hill |
183% |
90% |
99% |
48% |
180% |
0.98 |
| 2016 |
7 (97 KB) |
High Car High Goods |
215% |
105% |
119% |
57% |
216% |
1.16 |
| 2016 |
8 (98 KB) |
Medium Car High Goods |
186% |
99% |
104% |
55% |
217% |
1.09 |
| 2016 |
10 (97 KB) |
Medium Car Medium Goods |
174% |
90% |
97% |
49% |
191% |
0.99 |
| 2016 |
12 (98 KB) |
High Car Medium Goods |
203% |
96% |
112% |
51% |
190% |
1.06 |
| 2016 |
18 (97 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll D, Hi, Base) |
213% |
104% |
117% |
55% |
211% |
1.14 |
| 2016 |
19 (97 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll D, Low) Least Demand |
169% |
88% |
94% |
48% |
188% |
0.97 |
| 2016 |
21 (98 KB) |
(Sc II, Toll B, Base, Low Car, Hi GV) |
189% |
99% |
104% |
55% |
215% |
1.09 |
| 2016 |
23 (99 KB) |
(Sc III, Toll D, Hi) Most Demand |
236% |
110% |
128% |
57% |
214% |
1.21 |
| 2016 |
35 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A - M4 Northern Bias |
226% |
108% |
124% |
57% |
213% |
1.18 |
| 2016 |
36 (95 KB) |
System Test 2A - M3 Lautau Bias |
228% |
108% |
124% |
57% |
211% |
1.18 |
| 2016 |
37 (96 KB) |
System Test 2A without IWC |
222% |
106% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
38 (95 KB) |
System Test 2A without Route 81 |
222% |
106% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
39 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A without TST P1 Road |
222% |
106% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
40 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A without TMS Link |
224% |
107% |
122% |
57% |
214% |
1.18 |
| 2016 |
41 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A without TM Western Bypass |
222% |
106% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
42 (96 KB) |
System Test 2A without HK-Lautau Link |
224% |
108% |
122% |
57% |
217% |
1.19 |
| 2016 |
43 (96 KB) |
System Test 2A without HK North Bypass |
222% |
107% |
121% |
56% |
213% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
44 (98 KB) |
System Test 2A without Kln Norther Bypass So Kwun Wat to Tai Mo Shan Link |
219% |
106% |
120% |
56% |
212% |
1.16 |
| 2016 |
45 (95 KB) |
System Test 2A without TM-CLK Link |
222% |
107% |
121% |
57% |
216% |
1.18 |
| 2016 |
46 (98 KB) |
System Test 2A without Further Widening YL HW |
222% |
106% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
47 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A without IEC Imp |
222% |
107% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
48 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A without HK Rail |
223% |
107% |
122% |
57% |
213% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
49 (96 KB) |
System Test 2A without Siu Sai Wan Station |
221% |
106% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
50 (98 KB) |
System Test 2A without WR Yen Chow Street to TST |
223% |
107% |
122% |
56% |
213% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
51 (98 KB) |
System Test 2A without SE KL West-East Rail |
224% |
107% |
122% |
57% |
213% |
1.18 |
| 2016 |
52 (96 KB) |
System Test 2A without Outer Western Corridor |
224% |
107% |
122% |
57% |
213% |
1.18 |
| 2016 |
53 (96 KB) |
System Test 2A without MOSR Ext |
221% |
106% |
121% |
56% |
212% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
54 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A without XB Western Corridor |
222% |
107% |
121% |
56% |
213% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
55 (98 KB) |
Recommended Infrastructure with New Kowloon Northern Bypass & So Kwun Wat to Tai Mo Shan |
220% |
106% |
120% |
56% |
211% |
1.16 |
| 2016 |
64 (96 KB) |
with 2001 Road and 2006 Rail |
183% |
95% |
101% |
53% |
212% |
1.06 |
| 2016 |
75 (95 KB) |
High Xboder Case |
219% |
107% |
121% |
58% |
221% |
1.19 |
| *2016 |
82 (97 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - High Growth (Low End) |
220% |
107% |
120% |
57% |
215% |
1.17 |
| *2016 |
83 (98 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - High Growth (High End) |
248% |
114% |
134% |
59% |
219% |
1.25 |
| *2016 |
84 (96 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - Medium Growth |
179% |
92% |
99% |
50% |
191% |
1.01 |
| *2016 |
86 (96 KB) |
Recommended Transport Strategy - Low Growth |
145% |
76% |
80% |
41% |
159% |
0.83 |
| 2016 |
89 (97 KB) |
System Test 2A without Fourth Harbour Crossing |
222% |
107% |
121% |
57% |
213% |
1.17 |
| 2016 |
90 (96 KB) |
System Test 2A without T1 |
222% |
107% |
121% |
57% |
213% |
1.17 |
| |
|
|
| Notes: |
(I) |
Scenarios in bold refers to Recommended Transport Strategy of the respective design years. |
|
(ii) |
Scenarios marked with "*" have been tested using PATH air quality model. |